Skip navigation

32 Replies Latest reply on Dec 12, 2017 11:30 AM by Dennis Dohogne

Forum - Long Titles

Glenn Schroeder Sep 9, 2014 12:51 PM

I noticed we've been getting a fairly large number of Discussions with exceedingly long titles. I believe that's the result of the new setup for asking a question from the Home page. Where it says "Type your question" people seem to think they should type the question, which makes perfect sense, but that's actually the space for the Discussion title. Then clicking on "Ask it" takes you to the actual dialog box where you enter the body of the Discussion, insert screenshots, etc. I really don't think this was set up very well.

Re: Forum - Long Titles

Greg Jankowski Oct 13, 2014 5:51 PM (in response to Glenn Schroeder)

Great comment. This was out of the box functionality.
We are looking at ways to improve this ourselves and tie it back to MySolidWorks.
We will post some information and get feedback before we undertake this.
Like Show 3 Likes(3)

Actions
Re: Forum - Long Titles

Greg Jankowski Dec 2, 2014 12:00 PM (in response to Glenn Schroeder)

I did a investigation of all titles from the start of our community to present.

It seems like titles have gotten longer and the % of "bad" titles has grow, but I'm not clear it jumped significantly since the update.

But, we need to insure that titles are better and more effective for other to find and comment on.

Partial education and will look into ideas with search and the ask a question widget.
Like Show 3 Likes(3)

Actions
- Re: Forum - Long Titles
  
  Glenn Schroeder Feb 16, 2015 8:26 AM (in response to Greg Jankowski)
  
  I think this might show what I meant: i need to make a pencil looking thing....cone tip, on top of hex rod, then finishes off as circular rod. I figures drawing the profile of the cone tip, then revolve, then place a plane on bottom of come to extrude the hex from there, then another plane t . I don't remember this kind of thing before the Forum overhaul.
  
  Like Show 4 Likes(4)
  
  Actions
- Re: Forum - Long Titles
  
  Peter De Vlieger Feb 25, 2015 10:41 AM (in response to Greg Jankowski)
  
  E.G.:
  
  when making a model to then be CNC machined, do i need to draw the internal threads where the screws will go? or can i just mark in the 2D drawing something like M4x8?
  I just installed 2015 and I can not drag and drop components from toolbox, it gives me this message: "Unable to open read-only file'C:\SOLIDWOKS Data (2)\browserAnsi\inch\bolts and screws\hex head\hex bolt_ai" does anybody know how to fix this?
  I am attempting to create a file template that will read an environment variable and assign that to a template variable to be used as a file name. When running the template, I receive the error msg: The template uses the undefined environment variable 'Ne
  
  All just from the last week or so. Clear indication that the present lay out is confusing when you see long questions in the title and the body of the post being near indentical to the so called title.
  
  If you think you need to educate your users in using your UI, which should be straight forward, then chances are that the UI should be tweaked or at least the wording of some aspects of it.
  
  Like Show 3 Likes(3)
  
  Actions
  - Re: Forum - Long Titles
    
    Greg Jankowski Mar 2, 2015 9:36 AM (in response to Peter De Vlieger)
    
    Agreed. And we are trying to find a way to do this in a maintainable manner.
    
    Like Show 3 Likes(3)
    
    Actions
    - Re: Forum - Long Titles
      
      Chris Michalski Mar 2, 2015 9:47 AM (in response to Greg Jankowski)
      
      The simplest solution would likely be that when someone creates a question from that box, to move their text to the main text box for them to complete (instead of the current method of putting their question in the headline). Then remind them to enter a headline when they hit submit. This way the new users will automatically be steered towards the preferred way to present their question.
      
      Like Show 3 Likes(3)
      
      Actions
      - Re: Forum - Long Titles
        
        Glenn Schroeder Mar 2, 2015 10:33 AM (in response to Chris Michalski)
        
        Chris Michalski wrote:
        
        The simplest solution would likely be that when someone creates a question from that box, to move their text to the main text box for them to complete (instead of the current method of putting their question in the headline). Then remind them to enter a headline when they hit submit. This way the new users will automatically be steered towards the preferred way to present their question.
        
        I would suggest making the "HAVE A SOLIDWORKS QUESTION?" text the link instead of the "Ask it" button, and completely removing the "Type your question" box and the "Ask it" link.
        
        Like Show 2 Likes(2)
        
        Actions
    - Re: Forum - Long Titles
      
      Mark Kaiser Mar 2, 2015 10:53 AM (in response to Greg Jankowski)
      
      This thread is six months old.
      
      Could the solution be as simple as limiting the number of allowed characters in whatever box creates the title? Then the user might think twice about what they are entering and how.
      
      Or big flashy messages for those that just don't get it.
      
      Like Show 5 Likes(5)
      
      Actions
      - Re: Forum - Long Titles
        
        John Stoltzfus Mar 2, 2015 11:08 AM (in response to Mark Kaiser)
        
        Even with a shocking mouse - they just won't get it
        
        Like Show 4 Likes(4)
        
        Actions
        
        Re: Forum - Long Titles
        
        Mark Kaiser Mar 2, 2015 11:29 AM (in response to John Stoltzfus)
        
        What's the saying, 'life is like a box of chocolates...', or 'you just can't fix...', think you were headed for the latter, but the first sort of applies also.
        
        Like Show 4 Likes(4)
        
        Actions
        
        Re: Forum - Long Titles
        
        Erik Bilello Mar 2, 2015 2:58 PM (in response to John Stoltzfus)
        
        A shocking mouse? Just where can I get one of those? Or maybe two, the company is growing.
        
        Like Show 3 Likes(3)
        
        Actions
      - Re: Forum - Long Titles
        
        Kelvin Lamport Mar 2, 2015 11:13 AM (in response to Mark Kaiser)
        
        That would be way too simple for the Jive platform, Mark.
        
        Like Show 1 Likes(1)
        
        Actions
        
        Re: Forum - Long Titles
        
        Mark Kaiser Mar 2, 2015 11:30 AM (in response to Kelvin Lamport)
        
        Well, there's some code somewhere that must say how many characters you can stick in that box, or at least that's what I was thinking. So the Jive platform sounds a bit bloated.
        
        Like Show 2 Likes(2)
        
        Actions
Re: Forum - Long Titles

Glenn Schroeder Jun 1, 2015 8:37 AM (in response to Glenn Schroeder)

Still no better.
Like Show 5 Likes(5)

Actions
- Re: Forum - Long Titles
  
  Deepak Gupta Jun 1, 2015 12:55 PM (in response to Glenn Schroeder)
  
  Glenn I believe it more of educating people rather than blaming forum team. People needs to understand the difference between a post title and its body.
  
  Like Show 2 Likes(2)
  
  Actions
  - Re: Forum - Long Titles
    
    Jamil Snead Jun 1, 2015 1:12 PM (in response to Deepak Gupta)
    
    I think the problem is that there is a box on the homepage for starting a discussion and it instructs you to "Type your question" into the box. So people will type out a long question, then click the "Ask it" button. But then whatever you typed into that box automatically gets entered as the title of your new discussion. I believe that instead the text should probably get entered into the question area and the user should be required to create a new title.
    
    Like Show 5 Likes(5)
    
    Actions
  - Re: Forum - Long Titles
    
    Dwight Livingston Jun 1, 2015 1:17 PM (in response to Deepak Gupta)
    
    Deepak
    
    It's my opinion that the long titles are driven by the forum software. If the "ask a question" feature were a button, the questioner might then be helped by seeing in a new page a place in which to put a title, another box for the body, etc. As it is, the questioner sees only one box in which to type, and type they do. I wouldn't blame the newcomer when they are misdirected.
    
    Dwight
    
    Like Show 5 Likes(5)
    
    Actions
    - Re: Forum - Long Titles
      
      Deepak Gupta Jun 1, 2015 1:34 PM (in response to Dwight Livingston)
      
      I would agree somehow with you but still won't blame the software completely. For e.g. people would use funny fonts, all caps and similar things.
      
      "Ask a question" feature has a button which needs to clicked once they type in. And than that takes you through the category selection and finally to a page where one can easy see the details as where is title and where is body. So then they can easily change it.
      
      I only wish some how new people should read these threes post before starting a discussions: Frequently Asked Forum Questions, How to ask a good question in the API forum and Forum Posting
      
      Like Show 3 Likes(3)
      
      Actions
      - Re: Forum - Long Titles
        
        Chris Michalski Jun 1, 2015 1:44 PM (in response to Deepak Gupta)
        
        I would suggest trying to get stickies added like other forums, but 1) a lot of forums end up with so many stickies that noone reads them and 2) based on some of the questions asked recently some new posters haven't even read the SW help file so chances of them reading a sticky before posting aren't that good.
        
        Like Show 2 Likes(2)
        
        Actions
        
        Re: Forum - Long Titles
        
        Deepak Gupta Jun 1, 2015 1:54 PM (in response to Chris Michalski)
        
        I would say that this could be made a part of registration to go through some introductory posts on search, profile, how to ask questions, what information to include, etc.
        
        Like Show 2 Likes(2)
        
        Actions
        
        Re: Forum - Long Titles
        
        John Stoltzfus Jun 1, 2015 3:39 PM (in response to Deepak Gupta)
        
        Deepak, if most of us can't read the help files when we get the software......., surely we're not going to pass on our registration test will we??
        
        Like Show 3 Likes(3)
        
        Actions
  - Re: Forum - Long Titles
    
    Glenn Schroeder Jun 1, 2015 1:36 PM (in response to Deepak Gupta)
    
    Deepak Gupta wrote:
    
    Glenn I believe it more of educating people rather than blaming forum team. People needs to understand the difference between a post title and its body.
    
    Deepak,
    
    I'm afraid I'll have to respectfully disagree with you. As Jamil and Dwight said, the layout to start a Discussion from the Home page is very confusing. The members can be educated, as many of us have been, but it shouldn't be necessary.
    
    Like Show 2 Likes(2)
    
    Actions
    - Re: Forum - Long Titles
      
      Peter De Vlieger Jun 2, 2015 3:21 AM (in response to Glenn Schroeder)
      
      I have to agree with Glenn on this.
      
      If you have a product and a basic feature of it isn't been used correctly by the customer then changes are that the fault is with the product and not the customer. Because if it's a basic feature it shouldn't need the customer to be educated but it should be straightforward. Especially if one considers that the vast majority of people that use it are very technical people with a decent education, so if they tend not to use it as expected then I for one find it rich to blame the users.
      
      Too much these days the finger points at the customer for what are actual design flaws.
      
      It isn't about blaming people it's about questioning the design.
      
      Like Show 3 Likes(3)
      
      Actions
      - Re: Forum - Long Titles
        
        Sarah Dwight Sep 22, 2015 11:57 AM (in response to Peter De Vlieger)
        
        I am a new user (joined the forums in late June 2015) and this was frustrating and confusing and took me a while to figure out. I didn't want to jump in and ask my own questions until I had searched the forum to see if someone else had already asked it. No sense reinventing the wheel.
        
        From the homepage it looks like you can do that with the "have a question? type your question" box, but when you type your question and hit enter it brings up a popup to "choose a place". My initial response was "A place for what?" I went through the motions until I realized it wasn't the search function. Then I had to go back until I found the search button. I never even knew the "search all results' was an option because I would type my question and hit enter giving the page no time to reload the preview below it (which is a cool function, but not really useful unless you can read full titles).
        
        But it really does depend upon the type of forum user. Do they search the forum before asking their own questions? or Do they just ask anything and everything, not caring or understanding how that affects other community members and themselves for future visits? Do they just type a novel and leave the whole thing as the title?
        
        I would prefer language that states "Search the Forum" box on the homepage, then an option to "Start a Discussion" when you can't find for what you were looking.
        
        Like Show 6 Likes(6)
        
        Actions
        
        Re: Forum - Long Titles
        
        John Stoltzfus Sep 22, 2015 12:05 PM (in response to Sarah Dwight)
        
        Which is exactly why these two posts should be on the top page of the forum outlined in red and highlighted in yellow ----
        
        Forum Posting
        
        Frequently Asked Forum Questions
        
        Like Show 3 Likes(3)
        
        Actions
        
        Re: Forum - Long Titles
        
        Richard Wehmeyer Sep 22, 2015 2:27 PM (in response to Sarah Dwight)
        
        Thank you, Sarah! I have been posting here for a while, took a hiatus and lately find it difficult to search the forum. I don't know when it changed but it has been driving me nuts.
        
        Like Show 3 Likes(3)
        
        Actions
        
        Re: Forum - Long Titles
        
        Dennis Dohogne Dec 12, 2017 11:30 AM (in response to Sarah Dwight)
        
        Sarah Dwight wrote:
        
        I am a new user (joined the forums in late June 2015) and this was frustrating and confusing and took me a while to figure out. I didn't want to jump in and ask my own questions until I had searched the forum to see if someone else had already asked it. No sense reinventing the wheel.
        
        From the homepage it looks like you can do that with the "have a question? type your question" box, but when you type your question and hit enter it brings up a popup to "choose a place". My initial response was "A place for what?" I went through the motions until I realized it wasn't the search function. Then I had to go back until I found the search button. I never even knew the "search all results' was an option because I would type my question and hit enter giving the page no time to reload the preview below it (which is a cool function, but not really useful unless you can read full titles).
        
        But it really does depend upon the type of forum user. Do they search the forum before asking their own questions? or Do they just ask anything and everything, not caring or understanding how that affects other community members and themselves for future visits? Do they just type a novel and leave the whole thing as the title?
        
        I would prefer language that states "Search the Forum" box on the homepage, then an option to "Start a Discussion" when you can't find for what you were looking.
        It would be nice if under Actions => Start a discussion, the system encouraged the user to FIRST search the forum for hits against words in the proposed title before allowing the option to post. Better yet would be if it automatically did this search and showed the results asking something along the lines of "Is this what you are interested in?" and if the answer is No then taking the user to the next dialogue box to enter the supporting comments to the the title of their post.
        
        Like Show 4 Likes(4)
        
        Actions
Re: Forum - Long Titles

John Stoltzfus Jun 3, 2015 6:23 AM (in response to Glenn Schroeder)

Keeps on going .....
Like Show 2 Likes(2)

Actions
Re: Forum - Long Titles

Kenneth Barrentine Sep 22, 2015 2:02 PM (in response to Glenn Schroeder)
Here's my take on it.

Have A Question.png 16.0 KB

Ask Question Dialog Box.png 34.7 KB
Like Show 4 Likes(4)

Actions
Re: Forum - Long Titles

Tom dunn Sep 22, 2015 2:16 PM (in response to Glenn Schroeder)

Oh come on guys and gals! You/we were all knew at one point and time to the forum. New/old people make mistakes, that is how we all learn. I am sure after the new person types out there first post and sees what was posted they make a change the second time.

Tom
Like Show 2 Likes(2)

Actions
- Re: Forum - Long Titles
  
  Richard Wehmeyer Sep 22, 2015 2:35 PM (in response to Tom dunn)
  
  True, but it is awkward and confusing therefore we are here making our pitch to the developers to make a change for us and newcomers alike. I, for one, would like to see the discussion creation process changed a bit.
  
  Yes, new users will eventually figure it out, I will eventually get the hang of searching the forum, but if they want to make it better here are our suggestions.
  
  Like Show 3 Likes(3)
  
  Actions
- Re: Forum - Long Titles
  
  Peter De Vlieger Sep 23, 2015 3:04 AM (in response to Tom dunn)
  
  True, we all make mistakes.
  
  The point is however that the design as it stands leads to mistakes because of how it is worded and generally designed.
  
  If something is designed in such a manner that the correct way to use it is not self evident then it is bad design.
  
  Look at the post by Sarah Dwight
  ...I went through the motions until I realized it wasn't the search function. Then I had to go back until I found the search button....
  There is no valid reason to make anything more complicated then it needs to be nor should a tool used to help come with a manual, or a learning curve, to learn to use it's most basic functionality. Again, bad design.
  
  The question then remains why did anyone think this would pass muster and why can a piping designer like myself, who's native language isn't even English, see that and those that are in charge of it not?
  
  When the switch over to this 'new improved' forum was made one of the reasons for it was given that it would be easier to make changes to by those that maintain it. It's been a year since the original question and still nothing has changed.
  
  Like Show 4 Likes(4)
  
  Actions

Go to original post

More Like This

Incoming Links