-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Russ Johnston Jan 16, 2013 4:47 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)Simulation Benchmark V3 Results
Total Solution Time (sec) = 777 (12 min 59 s)
Number of Equations (490875) = Y
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2012/SP4.0
Computer Manufacturer = XI Computer
Computer Model = MTower
Approx System Cost = $3200
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Professional x64/SP1
Graphics Card = nVidia Quadro 4000
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = i7 2600K
CPU Clock Speed = 4.0 GHz
Cooling Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 4
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 16 GB
RAM Manufacturer = Corsair
RAM Speed = 1600 MHz
Hard Drive Size = 240 GB Corsair Force Series3
Hard Drive Type and RPM = SSD
Misc Notes:
Coolermaster V6 GT CPU cooler, ASUS P8P67-M motherboard
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Russ Johnston Jan 16, 2013 4:51 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)Simulation Benchmark V3 Results
Total Solution Time (sec) = 565 (9 min 25s)
Number of Equations (490875) = Y
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2012/SP4.0
Computer Manufacturer = XI Computer
Computer Model = PCIe Workstation
Approx System Cost = $3300
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Professional x64/SP1
Graphics Card = nVidia Quadro 2000
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = i7 3930K
CPU Clock Speed = 4.5 GHz
Cooling Type = Liquid Cooled
Number of Cores = 6
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 16 GB
RAM Manufacturer = Corsair
RAM Speed = 1866 MHz
Hard Drive Size = 240 GB Corsair Force Series 3
Hard Drive Type and RPM = SSD
Misc Notes:
Corsair H100 CPU cooler, ASUS P9X79 Pro motherboard
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Carl Gauger Jan 16, 2013 10:09 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)Below are the results I got running the new Benchmark. Note that the number of equations differed slightly. I decided to do a 2nd run and was suprised to see that the number of equations was slightly different again than either yours or my first run. Even more curious was the fact that the number of contact elements changed to 6 on the 2nd run. Not sure what's up there--I checked the mesh setting on both runs before solving. Even so, the solve time was not very significantly different.
Run 1:
Total Solution Time (sec) = 1009
Number of Equations (490875) = N (490038)
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2013/SP1
Computer Manufacturer = Built: MotherBoard = Gigabyte GA-Z77x-UD5H MB (Rev. 1.1)
Computer Model = Case: Antec 302
Approx System Cost < $1500
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Professional 64 bit / Service Pack 1
Graphics Card = AMD 100-505649 FirePro V4900, Driver 8.911.3.1000
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = Core i7 3770K
CPU Clock Speed = 3.5GHz
Cooling Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 4
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 32 GB
RAM Manufacturer = Ballistix
RAM Speed = 1600
Hard Drive Size = 256 GB
Hard Drive Type and RPM = Samsung 830 series E SATA SSD
Run 2:
Total Solution Time (sec) = 999
Number of Equations (490875) = N (430890)
Active Contact Elements (28) = N (6)
Everything else = as above
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Dave Laban Jan 17, 2013 3:54 AM (in response to Russ Johnston)Just downloaded the model so will hopefully get it running on a couple of machines later today. Thanks for all your effort with this benchmark.
Do we want to include the time to mesh in the results as well? Or did the previous thread establish it was just proportionate to processor clock speed?
Edit;
Results from first Workstation
Total Solution Time (sec) = 1494 (24min 54s)
Time to Mesh (sec) = 12
Number of Equations (490875) = Y
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2012/SP4.0
Computer Manufacturer = HP
Computer Model = xw8600 (purchased Jan 2009)
Approx System Cost = [unknown]
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Professional x64/SP1
Graphics Card = NVidia Quadro FX5800 (driver 8.17.11.9754)
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = Xeon X5492 (x2)
CPU Clock Speed = 3.40GHz
Cooling Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 8
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = No
Amount of RAM = 32Gb
RAM Manufacturer = [unknown]
RAM Speed = [unknown]
Hard Drive Size = 256Gb
Hard Drive Type and RPM = Crucial M4-CT256 M4 SSD2
Misc Notes: Terminal accessed using Windows Remote Desktop client, therefore graphics card was not being leveraged.
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Richard Bremmer Jan 17, 2013 4:12 PM (in response to Dave Laban)Hi Dave,
Could you do us a favour and rerun the test? Please set the simulation proces to use only one processor (4 cores). You can do that in the taskmanager, select the right process (probably cosmos) with the rmb and Set Affinity... This will give us some insight if for this particular study it is desirable to have two processors (8 cores) or if only one (4 cores) will do.
Regards
Richard
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Dave Laban Jan 18, 2013 5:18 AM (in response to Richard Bremmer)Hi Richard,
Good idea so I thought I'd try it. I figured only running cores 0-3 would put them all on the same physical processor, if that was mistaken let me know and I'll re-run it. I also upgraded from 12SP4 to 12SP5 so I re-ran the test with all 8 cores going for consistency.
So, with all resources available:
Total Solution Time (sec) = 1490 (24min 50s - I think a four second / 0.3% difference between Service Packs can be ignored?)
Time to Mesh (sec) = 12
Number of Equations (490875) = Y
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2012/SP5.0
Computer Manufacturer = HP
Computer Model = xw8600 (purchased Jan 2009)
Approx System Cost = [unknown]
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Professional x64/SP1
Graphics Card = NVidia Quadro FX5800 (driver 8.17.11.9754)
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = Xeon X5492 (x2)
CPU Clock Speed = 3.40GHz
Cooling Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 8
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = No
Amount of RAM = 32Gb
RAM Manufacturer = [unknown]
RAM Speed = [unknown]
Hard Drive Size = 256Gb
Hard Drive Type and RPM = Crucial M4-CT256 M4 SSD2And with resources limited:
Total Solution Time (sec) = 1943 (32min 23s - so there's definitely a speed difference, but not by as much as might be thought)
Time to Mesh (sec) = 12
Number of Equations (490875) = Y
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2012/SP5.0
Computer Manufacturer = HP
Computer Model = xw8600 (purchased Jan 2009)
Approx System Cost = [unknown]
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Professional x64/SP1
Graphics Card = NVidia Quadro FX5800 (driver 8.17.11.9754)
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = Xeon X5492 (x2 - Processor Affinity for star.exe modified to only use Core 0-3, changed as soon as possible after commencing analysis (while current task was listed as Iteration)).
CPU Clock Speed = 3.40GHz
Cooling Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 8 (reduced to 4 for star.exe)
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = No
Amount of RAM = 32Gb
RAM Manufacturer = [unknown]
RAM Speed = [unknown]
Hard Drive Size = 256Gb
Hard Drive Type and RPM = Crucial M4-CT256 M4 SSD2The attached .png shows task manager during the contact solving stage with only four of the cores active.
-
-
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Dave Laban Jan 17, 2013 4:13 AM (in response to Russ Johnston)Results from my general-purpose laptop.
Total Solution Time (sec) = 2484 (41min 24s)
Time to Mesh (sec) = 18
Number of Equations (490875) = Y
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2012/SP5.0
Computer Manufacturer = HP
Computer Model = 6930p
Approx System Cost = [unknown]
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Professional x64/SP1
Graphics Card = ATI Mobility Radeon HD3450 (driver 8.632.1.1000)
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = Core 2 Duo P8600
CPU Clock Speed = 2.40GHz
Cooling Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 2
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = No
Amount of RAM = 4Gb
RAM Manufacturer = [unknown]
RAM Speed = [unknown]
Hard Drive Size = 148Gb
Hard Drive Type and RPM = WDC WD1600BEKT-60F3T1 (mechanical, unsure of RPM)
Is it worth comparing not just CPU clockspeed for reference but also match against the test results from CPUBenchmark.net? As if there is good correlation with their scores it will make speccing a workstation a little easier.
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Jody Wilkerson Jan 21, 2013 9:52 AM (in response to Russ Johnston)Hi Russ,
Here are the results from my Xi machine. We have already switched to SW2013, so I can't get the results in SW2012 anymore.
I still got slower times than yours.
Total Mesh Time (sec) = 7
Total Solution Time = 834 (13min 54sec)
Number of Equations (490875) = N (I got 490038. This is the same as what Carl got on his 1st run so this might be due to SW2013)
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2013/SP1
Computer Manufacturer = Xi
Computer Model = MTower
Approx System Cost = $2843
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 x64
Graphics Card = nVidia Quadro 2000
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = Core i7-3770K
CPU Clock Speed = 4.5 GHz
Cooing Type = Liquid Cooled
Number of Cores = 4
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 16 GB
RAM Manufacturer = Corsair Vengance
RAM Speed = DDR3-1866
Hard Drive Size = 240GB SSD
Hard Drive Type and RPM = SSD
Misc Notes:
ASUS P8Z77-V Pro motherboard
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Riccardo Santambrogio Jan 22, 2013 11:21 AM (in response to Russ Johnston)Hi Russ,
simulation Benchmark V3 Results
Total Solution Time (sec) = 658 (10 min 58 s)
Number of Equations (490875) = Y
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2012/SP5.0
Computer Manufacturer = hp
Computer Model = z420
Approx System Cost = $4700
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 8 Professional x64
Graphics Card = nVidia Quadro 4000
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = xeon e5-1660
CPU Clock Speed = 3.3 GHz (turbo 3.9)
Cooling Type = liquid Cooled
Number of Cores = 6
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 16 GB
RAM Manufacturer = samsung
RAM Speed = 1600 MHz
Hard Drive Size = 240 GB
Hard Drive Type and RPM = SSD (oem)
Misc Notes:
workstation setup made by “HP Performance Advisor”. profile “solidworks 2012”
-
FEA_BENCHMARK-V3-Study 1.zip 4.2 KB
-
setup.pdf 170.6 KB
-
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
james demarco Jan 25, 2013 7:18 AM (in response to Russ Johnston)I also saw a slight variation in number of equations - advanced options was checked. I do have the same number of elements Jody reported.
simulation Benchmark V3 Results
Total Solution Time (sec) = 882 (14.7 min)
Number of Equations (490875) = N 490038
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2013/SP1.0
Computer Manufacturer = Alienware
Computer Model = R4
Approx System Cost = $4200?
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Professional x64 sp1.0
Graphics Card = GeForce GTX 555
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = i7-3930
CPU Clock Speed = 3.3 GHz
Cooling Type = liquid Cooled
Number of Cores = 6
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 16 GB
RAM Manufacturer = Dell
RAM Speed = 1600 MHz
Hard Drive Size = 240 GB
Hard Drive Type and RPM = SSD
Misc Notes:
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Phil Perlich Jan 24, 2013 2:42 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)Here are some results for another machine in our office. I don't know why the # of equations is off. I doubled checked step 3.
Total Solution Time (sec) = 1078 sec (~18 minutes)
Number of Equations (490875) = N (491,406)
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2012/SP4.0
Computer Manufacturer = Dell
Computer Model = Precision Work Station T7500
Approx System Cost = $900
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 SP1
Graphics Card = ???
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = Xeon E5620
CPU Clock Speed = 2.40 GHz
Cooing Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 4 cores/processor X 2 processor = 8 cores (8 logical/processor X 2 processors = 16 logical)
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = ???
Amount of RAM = 24 GB
RAM Manufacturer = ???
RAM Speed = ???
Hard Drive Size = 918 GB
Hard Drive Type and RPM = disk - speed = ???
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Philip Christensen Jan 25, 2013 3:36 AM (in response to Russ Johnston)Simulation benchmark V3 results:
Total Solution Time (sec) = 990 sec
Number of Equations (490875) = Y
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2012 Premium x64 SP4.0
Computer Manufacturer = Dell
Computer Model = Precision M6600
Approx System Cost = ?
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Enterprise SP1.0
Graphics Card = NVIDIA Quadro 4000M
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = i7-2760QM CPU
CPU Clock Speed = 2.40 GHz
Cooing Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 4
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 8 Gb
RAM Manufacturer = Samsung
RAM Speed = DDR3 1333 MHz
Hard Drive Size = 320 GB
Hard Drive Type and RPM = WDC - WD3200BEKT, SATA, 7200 RPM
Misc Notes: None
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Russ Johnston Jan 28, 2013 1:51 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)It appears that SW2013 is actually slower on this benchmark than SW2012 is.....
Simulation Benchmark V3 Results
Total Solution Time (sec) = 1029 (17 min 9 s) --> SW2012 Time = 777 (12 min 59 s)
Number of Equations (490875) = N (490038)
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2013/SP1.0
Computer Manufacturer = XI Computer
Computer Model = MTower
Approx System Cost = $3200
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Professional x64/SP1
Graphics Card = nVidia Quadro 4000
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = i7 2600K
CPU Clock Speed = 4.0 GHz
Cooling Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 4
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 16 GB
RAM Manufacturer = Corsair
RAM Speed = 1600 MHz
Hard Drive Size = 240 GB Corsair Force Series3
Hard Drive Type and RPM = SSD
Misc Notes:
Coolermaster V6 GT CPU cooler, ASUS P8P67-M motherboard
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
John Sutherland Feb 1, 2013 6:51 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)Thanks Russ for your effort.
We will never know if some mobos have sub optimal settings for jumpers or BIOS.
Comparing the 2.4 GHz Core 2 Duo vs. 2.4 GHz i7, I guess that the Core 2 also has a 7200 rpm drive and that the difference is in the extra RAM which enables avoidance of pagefile swapping in a slow I/O environment.
RAM frequency seems not to be significant.
I suspect that there is a wide range of SSD data rates.
Perhaps the Xeon X series has a very slow or flakey SSD.
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Cylo Master Feb 5, 2013 12:52 AM (in response to Russ Johnston)Hey Russ, Great post idea.
Would love to try out that simulation on my new machine, but i have SW 2011, A step or igs file would be great.
Thanks
Asus P9X79 LE
iNTEL i7 3820 3.60GHZ LGA2011
32GB DDR3 CORSAIR
SSD 256 OCZ
3TB Seagate BARC
NVIDIA QUADRO FX1800
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Russ Johnston Feb 5, 2013 11:41 AM (in response to Cylo Master)Cylo,
I can provide you with a IGES version of the file, but the FEA setup won't be in it. You will have to manually redo the setup. I've been working on a setup procedure for older than SolidWorks 2012 users but it's not quite done yet. When i have it complete I'll post it for you and others to use.
-
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Alessandro Tornincasa Feb 5, 2013 3:21 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)Hi Russ,
here are my results:
Total Solution Time (sec) = 1199 (from step 6 above)
Number of Equations (490875) = N (490038)
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2013/SP2
Computer Manufacturer = Dell
Computer Model = Precision M4600
Approx System Cost = 3000 $
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Professional SP1
Graphics Card = NVIDIA Quadro 2000M
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = Intel Core i7-2860QM CPU@2.5GHz 2.5 GHZ
CPU Clock Speed = 2.5 GHZ
Cooing Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 8
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 12 GB
RAM Manufacturer =
RAM Speed = 665.3 Mhz
I suspect this benchmark could run faster by tweaking some options. I'll post you later.
Alex
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Alessandro Tornincasa Feb 5, 2013 3:36 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)I was tinking about the general guidelines:
- sparse solver is faster when solving contacts
- node to surface is faster than surface to surface.
I'll make a couple of tests:
- direct sparse solver and node to surface
- direct sparse and surface to surace contact
I'll let you know my findings,
Alex
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Alessandro Tornincasa Feb 5, 2013 4:45 PM (in response to Alessandro Tornincasa)direct sparse solver and node to surface
Total Solution Time (sec) = 958 (from step 6 above)
Number of Equations (490875) = N (490038)
Active Contact Elements (28) = N (10)
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2013/SP2
Computer Manufacturer = Dell
Computer Model = Precision M4600
Approx System Cost = 3000 $
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Professional SP1
Graphics Card = NVIDIA Quadro 2000M
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = Intel Core i7-2860QM CPU@2.5GHz 2.5 GHZ
CPU Clock Speed = 2.5 GHZ
Cooing Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 8
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 12 GB
RAM Manufacturer =
RAM Speed = 665.3 Mhz
It seems that there's less solver time because there are less contact elements.
Alex
-
T2.zip 2.6 KB
-
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Alessandro Tornincasa Feb 5, 2013 4:50 PM (in response to Alessandro Tornincasa)direct sparse and surface to surace contact
Total Solution Time (sec) = 1323 (from step 6 above)
Number of Equations (490875) = N (490038)
Active Contact Elements (28) = N (22)
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2013/SP2
Computer Manufacturer = Dell
Computer Model = Precision M4600
Approx System Cost = 3000 $
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Professional SP1
Graphics Card = NVIDIA Quadro 2000M
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = Intel Core i7-2860QM CPU@2.5GHz 2.5 GHZ
CPU Clock Speed = 2.5 GHZ
Cooing Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 8
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 12 GB
RAM Manufacturer =
RAM Speed = 665.3 Mhz
Hmmm, more solution time and less contact elements. And the direct sparse was supposed to be faster. I'm puzzled...
Alex
-
T3.zip 4.0 KB
-
-
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Alessandro Tornincasa Feb 5, 2013 4:52 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)Ok, there's one last test that should be tried:
- switching surface and target in the contact set and using iterative solver
switching surface and target in the contact set and using direct sparse solver
Alex
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Vittorio Villani Feb 12, 2013 6:26 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)Simulation Benchmark V3 Results
Total Solution Time (sec) = 1056
Number of Equations (490875)
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2013/SP1.0
Computer Manufacturer =
Computer Model =
Approx System Cost =
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Ultimate x64/SP1
Graphics Card = nVidia Quadro K5000M
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = i7 920
CPU Clock Speed = 3.9 GHz
Cooling Type = Water cooled
Number of Cores = 4 (8 HT)
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 24 GB
RAM Manufacturer = Corsair
RAM Speed = 780 MHz
Hard Drive Size = Samsung 830 - 256Gbyte
Hard Drive Type and RPM = SSD
Thanks again for the nice work that you did with this benchmark. I'll try to run the bench on other computers and let you know.
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Vittorio Villani Feb 12, 2013 7:01 PM (in response to Vittorio Villani)Disabiling a few services in Windows (and using the basic graphic settings) I saved about 50 seconds.
Total Solution Time (sec) = 1007
Number of Equations (490038)
I don't understand why I always get a different number of equations.
-
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Chris Ross Feb 13, 2013 1:42 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)Total Solution Time (sec) = 755 (from step 6 above)
Number of Equations (490875) = Y
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2012/SP5
Computer Manufacturer = Me
Computer Model =
Approx System Cost = $3000
Operating System and Service Pack = Win 7 64 bit SP 1
Graphics Card = PNY Quadro 4000
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = i7-3930
CPU Clock Speed = 3.2 GHz
Cooing Type = Liquid Cooled
Number of Cores = 6
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = N
Amount of RAM = 16GB (4x4GB)
RAM Manufacturer = G.Skill
RAM Speed = DDR3 1866
Hard Drive Size = 480
Hard Drive Type and RPM = Intel Cherryville SSD
Misc Notes:
Motherboard = ASUS P9X79 Deluxe LGA
Case = Cooler Master Cosmos II
Cooler = Corsair Hydro H100 Liquid Cooler
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Russ Johnston Feb 19, 2013 9:47 AM (in response to Chris Ross)Chris,
Can you confirm your actual CPU clock speed? 3.2 GHz is the stock speed for you processor and based on your results I'm guessing your system is overclocked. I'm guessing somewhere around 4.0 GHz. If it is overclocked please update your post.
-
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Vittorio Villani Feb 27, 2013 8:43 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)Simulation Benchmark V3 Results
Total Solution Time (sec) = 716
Number of Equations (490038)
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2013/SP2.0
Computer Manufacturer =
Computer Model =
Approx System Cost =
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 8 Pro
Graphics Card = nVidia Quadro K5000
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = i7 3960x
CPU Clock Speed = 4.5 GHz
Cooling Type = Water cooled
Number of Cores = 6 (12 HT)
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 16 GB
RAM Manufacturer = Corsair
RAM Speed = 800 MHz
Hard Drive Size = Samsung 830 - 256Gbyte
Hard Drive Type and RPM = SSD
First test for me with no software optimiziation.
-
FEA_BENCHMARK-V3-Study 1.zip 4.3 KB
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Vittorio Villani Feb 28, 2013 6:59 AM (in response to Vittorio Villani)I run again the test with CoreTemp and CPU-Z to check temperatures and frequencies.
At 4.5Ghz the test takes 710-720 sec depending on how many tasks are running in Windows 8.
The max temperature running this benchmark and the standard SolidWorks benchmark is 55°. When running Prime95 the temperature reaches about 60°. Room temperature is set to 24° (maybe it is a little lower now). When the screen show was taken, Prime95 was running on all cores:
-
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Bill Markert Feb 28, 2013 2:23 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)Simulation Benchmark V3 Results
I am posting two results for the new system I have just put together. The first is for the standard Turbo setting for the processor (peaks at about 4.1 Ghz) and the second is for the extreme overclocking software setup (set at 4.74 Ghz). These clocking options are part of the ASUS motherboard control software that runs in windows.
Total Solution Time (sec) = 822 (13 min 42 s)
Number of Equations (490875) =N - 490038
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2013/SP0.0
Computer Manufacturer = Home built
Computer Model =
Approx System Cost = $3000
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Professional x64/SP1
Graphics Card = AMD FirePro V4900
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = i7 3970X
CPU Clock Speed = 4.12 GHz
Cooling Type = Water Cooled
Number of Cores = 6
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 32 GB
RAM Manufacturer = Corsair Vengeance
RAM Speed = 1866 MHz
Hard Drive Size = 480 GB Corsair Neutron GTX
Hard Drive Type and RPM = SSD
Misc Notes:
Corsair H100 CPU cooler, ASUS P9X79 DELUXE motherboard, ASUS Stormtrooper Case
With the extreme over clocking setup:
Total Solution Time (sec) = 742 (12 min 22 s)
CPU Clock Speed = 4.74 GHz
Misc Notes:
I set the H100 fans to high so the system was noiser than I would like for a long period but the processor peaked early at only 64C max then settled down between 45C to 55C, so not bad and the fans never went to full rpm.
I didn't think to save results so I don't have either out file to post. If there is interest I can rerun the benchmarks and post the out files.
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Riccardo Santambrogio Mar 1, 2013 5:22 AM (in response to Russ Johnston)Hi Ross,
I confirm your data. 2013 sp3 is slower than 2012 sp5 on w8-64
Simulation Benchmark V3 Results
Total Solution Time (sec) = 862 (14 min 20 s) --> SW2012 Time = 658 (10 min 58 s)
Number of Equations (490875) = N (490038)
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2013/SP3.0
Computer Manufacturer = HP
Computer Model = z420
Approx System Cost = $4700
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 8 pro 64 bit
Graphics Card = nVidia Quadro 4000
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = Xeon e5-1660
CPU Clock Speed = 3.3 (turbo 3.9) GHz
Cooling Type = Liquid Cooled
Number of Cores = 6
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 16 GB
RAM Manufacturer = Samsung
RAM Speed = 1600 MHz
Hard Drive Size = 240 GB
Hard Drive Type and RPM = SSD
Misc Notes:
workstation setup made by “HP Performance Advisor”. profile “solidworks 2012/213”
-
setup.pdf 170.6 KB
-
FEA_BENCHMARK-V3-Study 1.zip 4.2 KB
-
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Justin Strempke Apr 2, 2013 12:05 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)Total Solution Time (sec) = 1243 (20 min 43 s)
Number of Equations (490875) = N, 490038
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SWX2013 SP2
Computer Manufacturer = HARDCORE
Computer Model = REACTOR
Approx System Cost = Unknown
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Ultimate x64 SP 1
Graphics Card = NVIDIA Quadro 4000 2GB
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = i7 Extreme x990
CPU Clock Speed = 3.47, (Turbo 4.3) GHz
Cooing Type = Liquid Cooled
Number of Cores = 6
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = N
Amount of RAM = 16GB DDR3
RAM Manufacturer = Unknown
RAM Speed = 1366 Mhz
Hard Drive Size = 300 GB
Hard Drive Type and RPM = SSD
Misc Notes:
Submerged motherboard (Greencity x58)
I'll run on SW2012 SP5 here in a bit to check on my machine if there's much difference. Also not 100% sure on the RAM speed, CPUZ is a bit cryptic to me on the true speed. Gives NB at 2600 MHz, DRAM at 537, FSB 2:8, and CR=2T. From DRAM*CR it should be ~1080 MHz, but the winstat memory test showed teh 1366 MHz value...
.OUT file for 2013 run
UPDATES:
2012 run:
Total Solution Time (sec) = 938 (15 min 38 s)
Number of Equations (490875) = Y
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SWX2012 SP5
Hyper-Threading enabled for comparison:
2013 time: 1226 s (20 min 26 s)
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Brian Dallos Apr 8, 2013 3:33 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)Total Solution Time (sec) = 1198
Number of Equations (490875) = 490038
Active Contact Elements (28) = 28
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SWX2013 SP2
Computer Manufacturer = Dell
Computer Model = M6600
Approx System Cost = $3000+
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Professional x64 SP 1
Graphics Card = NVIDIA Quadro 3000M 2GB
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = i7-2760QM
CPU Clock Speed = 2.40GHz
Cooing Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 4
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 8GB DDR3
RAM Manufacturer = Dell
RAM Speed = 1333 Mhz
Hard Drive Size = 2x 500 GB
Hard Drive Type and RPM = SATA, 7200, RAID 1
Misc Notes:
This is my daily use laptop. Not normally used to run simulations only to view results.
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Brian Dallos Apr 8, 2013 3:46 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)Total Solution Time (sec) = 1226
Number of Equations (490875) = 490038
Active Contact Elements (28) = 28
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SWX2013 SP2
Computer Manufacturer = Dell
Computer Model = T7500
Approx System Cost = $3000+
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Enterprise x64 SP 1
Graphics Card = NVIDIA Quadro FX570
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = 2x Xeon X5550
CPU Clock Speed = 2.67GHz
Cooing Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 2x 4
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 24GB DDR3
RAM Manufacturer = Dell
RAM Speed = 1333 Mhz
Hard Drive Size = 3x 146 GB (270GB Total)
Hard Drive Type and RPM = SAS, 15000, RAID 5
Misc Notes:
This is one of several simulation boxes used daily. Build date of 12/21/2009.
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Brian Dallos Apr 8, 2013 4:16 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)This machine is a little bit different than any of the other machines posted here. This is one of 2/3 virtual machine set up on a Dell PowerEdge R710. I'll first post the specs for the virtual machine then I'll post the details of the entire server.
Virtual Machine
Total Solution Time (sec) = 1333
Number of Equations (490875) = 490038
Active Contact Elements (28) = 28
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SWX2013 SP2
Computer Manufacturer = Virtual
Computer Model = NA
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Enterprise x64 SP 1
Graphics Card = None
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = Xeon X5690
CPU Clock Speed = 3.47GHz
Cooing Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 4
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = N
Amount of RAM = 60GB DDR3
RAM Manufacturer = Dell
RAM Speed = 1333 Mhz
Hard Drive Size = 80GB Windows Partition/ 224GB Data Partition
Hard Drive Type and RPM = NA
Server
Computer Manufacturer = Dell
Computer Model = PowerEdge R710
Approx System Cost = $10000
Operating System and Service Pack = VMware v Sphere 4 Standard
Graphics Card = None
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = 2x Xeon X5690
CPU Clock Speed = 3.47GHz
Cooing Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 2x 6
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = N
Amount of RAM = 96GB DDR3
RAM Manufacturer = Dell
RAM Speed = 1333 Mhz
Hard Drive Size = 2x 73 GB(VMware)/6x 300GB (virtual machines)
Hard Drive Type and RPM = SAS/SAS, 15k/10k, 6Gbps/6Gbps, RAID 1/RAID 5
Misc Notes:
This box currently has the RAM from 2 of he virtual machines dedicated to it. The virtual machines can be taken down and resources reallocated as necessary. Typical run 2-5 machines simulateously. This and simulation box detailed in the previous post are exclusively used for steady state and transient(1k-2k step) thermal and flow simulations.
Update: 2 other studies were being run concurrently on a different virtual machine.
Message was edited by: Brian Dallos
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Tony Gatta Apr 23, 2013 7:36 AM (in response to Russ Johnston)Total Solution Time (sec) = 1622
Number of Equations (490875) = Y
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2012/SP4
Computer Manufacturer = Lenovo
Computer Model = W510 (laptop workstation)
Approx System Cost = ~$2500
Operating System and Service Pack = Win 7 Pro SP1
Graphics Card = Quadro FX 880M
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = Core i7
CPU Clock Speed =
Cooing Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 4
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 16GB
RAM Manufacturer =
RAM Speed =
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Matthew Jackson Apr 23, 2013 12:08 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)Hi All,
I have solved the following FE models:
- Iterative Solver Surface to Surface Contact
- Iterative Solver Surface to Surface Contact Hyperthreading
- Iterative Solver Node to Surface Contact
- Iterative Solver Node to Surface Contact Hyperthreading
- Sparse Solver Surface to Surface Contact
- Sparse Solver Surface to Surface Contact Hyperthreading
- Sparse Solver Node to Surface Contact
- Sparse Solver Node to Surface Contact Hyperthreading
My machine details are:
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2013/SP3
Computer Manufacturer = Cryo Performance Computing
Computer Model = NA
Approx System Cost = £8,000
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Service Pack 1
Graphics Card = NVIDIA Quadro FX 4800
CPU Brand = INTEL
CPU Model = i7
CPU Clock Speed = 4.26 GHz
Cooing Type = Liquid Cooled
Number of Cores = 6
Amount of RAM = 12 GB
RAM Manufacturer = Corsair
RAM Speed = 2000 MHz
Hard Drive Size = 128 GB
Hard Drive Type and RPM = SSD
Misc Notes:
Motherboard ASUS D33005
Results are:
Iterative Solver Surface to Surface Contact
Total Solution Time (sec) = 897 (14 min 57 sec)
Number of Equations (490875) = N (490038)
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
Iterative Solver Surface to Surface Contact Hyper Threading
Total Solution Time (sec) = 866 (14 min 26 sec)
Number of Equations (490875) = N (490038)
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
Iterative Solver Node to Surface Contact
Total Solution Time (sec) = 875 (14 min 35 sec)
Number of Equations (490875) = N (490038)
Active Contact Elements (28) = N (11)
Iterative Solver Node to Surface Contact Hyper Threading
Total Solution Time (sec) = 891 (14 min 51 sec)
Number of Equations (490875) = N (490038)
Active Contact Elements (28) = N (11)
Sparse Solver Surface to Surface Contact
Total Solution Time (sec) = 969 (16 min 9 sec)
Number of Equations (490875) = N (490038)
Active Contact Elements (28) = N (22)
Sparse Solver Surface to Surface Contact Hyper Threading
Total Solution Time (sec) = 864 (14 min 24 sec)
Number of Equations (490875) = N (490038)
Active Contact Elements (28) = N (22)
Sparse Solver Node to Surface Contact
Total Solution Time (sec) = 700 (11 min 40 sec)
Number of Equations (490875) = N (490038)
Active Contact Elements (28) = N (10)
Sparse Solver Node to Surface Contact Hyper Threading
Total Solution Time (sec) = 606 (10 min 6 sec)
Number of Equations (490875) = N (490038)
Active Contact Elements (28) = N (10)
Thanks
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Linn Tun May 7, 2013 9:10 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)Dear all,
I've done benchmarking with new machine. Results are as follows:
Total Solution Time (sec) = 753
Number of Equations (490875) =N - 490038
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2013/SP3.0
Computer Manufacturer = Home built
Computer Model =
Approx System Cost =
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Professional x64
Graphics Card = AMD FirePro V5900
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = i7 3970X
CPU Clock Speed = 4.87 GHz
Cooling Type = Water Cooled Corsair h80i
Number of Cores = 6
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 32 GB
RAM Manufacturer = G.SKILL
RAM Speed =
Hard Drive Size = Samsung 840 Series 256GB
Hard Drive Type and RPM = SSD
-
FEA_BENCHMARK-V3-Study 1.zip 4.3 KB
-
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Greg Muller May 17, 2013 6:32 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)Just ran it... ouch.
Total Solution Time (sec) = 2525
Number of Equations (490875) = Y
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2012/SP4
Computer Manufacturer = Dell
Computer Model = Precision T3400
Approx System Cost = $2000
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Professional PS1
Graphics Card = NVIDIA Quadro FX 570
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = Core(TM)2 Duo CPU E7300
CPU Clock Speed = 2.66GHz
Cooing Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 2
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = N
Amount of RAM = 4.00 GB
RAM Manufacturer = ?
RAM Speed = ?
Hard Drive Size = 233 GB
Hard Drive Type and RPM = 7200 RPM
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Russ Johnston May 22, 2013 8:31 AM (in response to Russ Johnston)Simulation Benchmark V3 Results
Total Solution Time (sec) = 745(12 min 25s)
Number of Equations (490875) = N (490038)
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2013/SP2.0
Computer Manufacturer = XI Computer
Computer Model = PCIe Workstation
Approx System Cost = $3300
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Professional x64/SP1
Graphics Card = nVidia Quadro 2000
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = i7 3930K
CPU Clock Speed = 4.5 GHz
Cooling Type = Liquid Cooled
Number of Cores = 6
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 16 GB
RAM Manufacturer = Corsair
RAM Speed = 1866 MHz
Hard Drive Size = 240 GB Corsair Force Series 3
Hard Drive Type and RPM = SSD
Misc Notes:
Corsair H100 CPU cooler, ASUS P9X79 Pro motherboard
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Russ Johnston May 22, 2013 8:36 AM (in response to Russ Johnston)Results Updated - 22-MAY-13
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Russ Johnston Jul 22, 2013 11:50 AM (in response to Russ Johnston)Simulation Benchmark V3 Results
Total Solution Time (sec) = 887 (14 min 47s)
Number of Equations (490875) = N (490038)
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2013/SP2.0
Computer Manufacturer = XI Computer
Computer Model = PCIe Workstation
Approx System Cost = $2900
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Professional x64/SP1
Graphics Card = NVIDIA Quadro K2000
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = i7 4770K
CPU Clock Speed = 4.5 GHz
Cooling Type = Liquid Cooled
Number of Cores = 4
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 16 GB
RAM Manufacturer = Corsair
RAM Speed = 1866 MHz
Hard Drive Size = 240 GB Corsair Neutron Series
Hard Drive Type and RPM = SSD
Misc Notes:
Corsair H100i CPU cooler, ASUS Z87 Deluxe motherboard
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Owen Buttigieg Oct 8, 2013 4:43 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)FEA_BENCHMARK-V3.SLDPRT
Total Mesh Time (sec) = 7 sec
Total Solution Time (sec) = 351 sec (5min 51sec)
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2014/SP0
Computer Manufacturer = home built
Computer Model =
Approx System Cost = $2,600
Operating System and Service Pack = W8
Graphics Card = Quadro 4000
CPU Brand = INTEL
CPU Model = 3930k
CPU Clock Speed = 4.6
Cooing Type = Liquid Cooled
Number of Cores = 6
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 32
RAM Manufacturer = G.Skill
RAM Speed = 1687
Hard Drive Size = 250
Hard Drive Type and RPM = Samsung 840 Evo
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Owen Buttigieg Oct 8, 2013 6:48 PM (in response to Owen Buttigieg)I didn't have the advanced options ticked it was slightly slower result and here is a bench of my new HDD. Nearly 1100 MB/s.
T O T A L S Y S T E M D A T A
NUMBER OF EQUATIONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(NEQ) = 490038
NUMBER OF ELEMENTS. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(NUME) = 111897
NUMBER OF NODAL POINTS. . . . . . . . . . . . .(NUMNP)= 167686
T O T A L S O L U T I O N T I M E (sec) . . . . = 363
-
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Tom Smith Oct 9, 2013 10:19 AM (in response to Russ Johnston)Total Solution Time (sec) = 911 (15m 11s)
Number of Equations (490875) = N
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2014/SP0
Computer Manufacturer = Dell
Computer Model = T3600
Approx System Cost = 2100 usd
Operating System and Service Pack = Win7 x64 SP1
Graphics Card = nvidia Quadro 4000
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = Xeon E5-1620
CPU Clock Speed = 3.6 GHZ
Cooing Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 4
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 16Gb
RAM Manufacturer = DDR3 unknown
RAM Speed = unknown
Hard Drive Size = 240 GB
Hard Drive Type and RPM = Dell PERC H310 SCSI SSD
Contact set advanced options = Y
NUMBER OF EQUATIONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(NEQ) = 490038
NUMBER OF ELEMENTS. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(NUME) = 111897
NUMBER OF NODAL POINTS. . . . . . . . . . . . .(NUMNP)= 167686
Looks like 2014 is leaving out ~800 equations for some reason
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Roy Dean Oct 11, 2013 12:00 PM (in response to Tom Smith)Tom, I got the same number (490038) with 2013 just now.....
-
-
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Bill Markert Oct 28, 2013 9:47 AM (in response to Russ Johnston)Russ
Reran benchmark with current computer using 2014 SP0
Total Solution Time (sec) = 420 (7 min)
Number of Equations (490875) =N - 490038
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2014/SP0.0
Computer Manufacturer = Home built
Computer Model =
Approx System Cost = $3000
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Professional x64/SP1
Graphics Card = AMD FirePro V4900
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = i7 3970X
CPU Clock Speed = 4.20GHz (Setup as Turbo all Cores drops as low as 1.2 GHZ with low processor demand)
Cooling Type = Water Cooled
Number of Cores = 6
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 32 GB
RAM Manufacturer = Corsair Vengeance
RAM Speed = 1866 MHz
Hard Drive Size = 480 GB Corsair Neutron GTX
Hard Drive Type and RPM = SSD
Misc Notes:
Corsair H100 CPU cooler, Gigabyte X79-UP4 motherboard, ASUS Stormtrooper Case
I've made some changes to the system since my original post with it early in the year. Most importantly I have swapped out motherboards. I had a motherboard failure with the ASUS P9X79 Deluxe I originally had in June and was sent a refurbished board with a highly intermittent hardware fault. After many weeks on my own then some professional help I fixed the system problem by replacing the motherboard. Net result is the system runs about 5% slower with the Gigabyte board in its current conservative overclock state.
My experience with ASUS support was very poor to the point where I will never use and do not recommend anyone else uses ASUS hardware. Hardware is nice but customer service is atrocious.
I also replaced all the fans with Noctua fans. A bit pricey but the silence is golden!
Bill Markert
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Eric Andersen Nov 6, 2013 3:04 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)Total Solution Time (sec) = 3348
Number of Equations (490875) = N 490038, "Show advanced options for contact set definition" was checked.
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y or N
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2013/SP2
Computer Manufacturer = Dell
Computer Model = Precision T5400
Approx System Cost = $2000? (It was purchased long before I got here)
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Pro x64 SP1
Graphics Card = nVidia Quadro FX 1700, 512 MB
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = Xeon E5260 (Wolfdale)
CPU Clock Speed = 3.33 GHz
Cooing Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 2
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = N
Amount of RAM = 8GB
RAM Manufacturer = OEM
RAM Speed = 332MHz
Hard Drive Size = 250 GB
Hard Drive Type and RPM = WD VelociRaptor 10,000 RPM
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Antonijo Kovacevic Nov 13, 2013 1:02 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)Total Solution Time (sec) = 873
Time to Mesh (sec) = 5
Number of Equations (490875) = N (490038)
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2013/SP5
Computer Manufacturer = Homebuild
Computer Model =
Approx System Cost = $1700
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Pro x64/SP1
Graphics Card = nVidia Quadro K2000
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = i5 4670k
CPU Clock Speed = 4,5
Cooing Type = Liquid Cooled
Number of Cores = 4
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = N
Amount of RAM = 32GB
RAM Manufacturer = Corsair
RAM Speed = 1600 MHz
Hard Drive Size = 250 GB
Hard Drive Type and RPM = SSD
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Daniel Ruf Nov 15, 2013 1:02 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)Workstation 1
Simulation Benchmark V3 Results
Total Solution Time (sec) = 1259 (20 min 59 s)
Number of Equations (490038) = Y
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2013/SP5.0
Computer Manufacturer =
Computer Model =
Approx System Cost =
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Professional x64/SP1
Graphics Card = nVidia Quadro 4000
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = i7 960
CPU Clock Speed = 3.2 GHz
Cooling Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 4
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 12 GB
RAM Manufacturer =
RAM Speed =
Hard Drive Size =
Hard Drive Type and RPM = HDD
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Daniel Ruf Nov 15, 2013 1:02 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)Workstation 2
Simulation Benchmark V3 Results
Total Solution Time (sec) = 2139 (35 min 39 s)
Number of Equations (490038) = Y
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2013/SP5.0
Computer Manufacturer =
Computer Model =
Approx System Cost =
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Professional x64/SP1
Graphics Card = ATI FireGL V8650
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = Core2 Duo Extreme X9650
CPU Clock Speed = 3 GHz
Cooling Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 4
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 8 GB
RAM Manufacturer =
RAM Speed =
Hard Drive Size =
Hard Drive Type and RPM = HDD
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
John Doe Nov 25, 2013 11:24 AM (in response to Russ Johnston)Some are running Xeon, others i7s......... Looking at this thread to see if I can get the fastest system...
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Shawn Mahaney Nov 26, 2013 10:23 AM (in response to Russ Johnston)I tried to explain to IT that my box at home with a $320 i7-3770k would run circles around any Xeon box they could afford, but this newish machine is still four times faster than the old dual-cpu machine I had.
Total Solution Time (sec) = 957
Number of Equations (490875) = N [490038]
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2014 / SP4.0
Computer Manufacturer = Dell
Computer Model = T3600
Approx System Cost = $4500
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 SP1 64 bit
Graphics Card = nVidia K4000
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = Xeon E5-1650
CPU Clock Speed = 3.2 GHz
Cooing Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 6
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 16 GB
RAM Manufacturer =
RAM Speed = 1600 MHz
Hard Drive Size = 237 GB
Hard Drive Type and RPM =
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Ivan Collins Dec 3, 2013 4:42 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)Total Solution Time (sec) = 740
Number of Equations (490875) = N (490038)
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2014/SP0
Computer Manufacturer =home built
Computer Model =
Approx System Cost =
Operating System and Service Pack =Windows 7 pro 64 bit
Graphics Card =G-Force GTX5500ti
CPU Brand =intel
CPU Model =i5-2500k
CPU Clock Speed =3.3
Cooing Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores =4
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = N
Amount of RAM =16
RAM Manufacturer =Corstar
RAM Speed =
Hard Drive = 250 GB
Hard Drive Type and RPM = HDD
My computer seems pretty fast in comparison to some of these posted. I ran it twice with the same results. I double checked the step 3 and made sure it was checked. We are wanting to build a faster machine and that machine that Owen Buttigieg posted seems pretty quick. Why has no one posted a dual or even quad CPU AMD machine or any AMD machine for that matter? We were looking into the water cooled i7 3930 overclocked versus dual AMD opterons water cooled and overclocked and by the numbers the AMD's seem like it could be a smoking fast machine.
Anyways this is my first post on the forums, been following and searching threads for a long time just never posted.
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Ben Foley Mar 5, 2014 10:35 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)Hi all. Great thread.
I've been taking a look at all of the simulations you've done so far in the hope of deriving specs for my new machine. I thought I'd post up my analysis which summarises the data and conclusions from the data available up until now.
The first thing I noted is that solidworks 2013 is slower than solidworks 2012 for the same machine, so I scaled all the 2012 simulations to estimate how long they would take in 2013.
After having an initial play, it seems the most important factor in simulation speed is CPU speed, so I graphed CPU speed vs the 2013 normalised simulation times.
In the above plot, lower scores are better. You can see that CPU speed does have an effect though it's not spectacular.
The next question I had was how many cores should I get. So, I normalised the simulation times to ignore processor speed (assuming an inverse linear relationship between CPU speed and simulation time), then plotted against the number of cores.
It seems pretty clear from the above graph that number of cores matters until you get to 6, after which there is no discernable advantage (though more data with 8 cores might disprove this).
I then looked at any correlations with RAM speed or quantity with essentially no relationship found, suggesting that provided you have the 16GB most had, the speed and quantity don't really matter (though with large assemblies I expect it would matter).
Conclusions:
- CPU Speed is important.
- Number of CPU Cores is important, but more than 6 is unnecessary.
- Core 2 Duo's arent very good, but i5, i7 and Xeons are essentially equal.
- Amount of RAM is not important (for the simulation at least).
- Speed of RAM is not important.
I'm using this to advise my boss on which components to focus money on and will post up test results when the new rig arrives.
Excel sheet attached for those interested or wanting to extend the analysis.
I hope this helps someone in the future.
-
Benchmarks.xlsx 32.5 KB
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Ivan Collins Mar 7, 2014 11:13 AM (in response to Ben Foley)How did you get a 8 core i7?
Cool study, I have found this to be pretty accurate. We just built a 4930 core i7 liquid cooled (4.6 ghz) setup and can get 351 second sim times on the benchmark study. We haven't really even optimised our setup yet so I think we can pull some more. Oddly enough when I updated my graphics card driver I picked up a couple seconds so that may be somewhat of a variable. We have a W5000 AMD card.
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Jared Conway Mar 7, 2014 11:58 AM (in response to Ben Foley)these are basically the same results presented in the solidworks KB as performed by solidworks.
i'll add that something that makes a big difference is SSD.
and for your comment about ram. if you've got a million GB of ram and your problem only uses 1GB, it won't help. but if you're paging, because your problem needs 8GB of ram, having the ram will help. speed of RAM won't help unless there is a serious delta between the speeds.
-
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Glenn Scully Mar 16, 2014 1:10 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)Total Solution Time (sec) = 1027 (17 min 7 secons)
Number of Equations (490875) = Y
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2012/SP4.0
Computer Manufacturer = Dell
Computer Model = T3500
Approx System Cost = ($700 used)
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 64 SP1
Graphics Card = Nvdia Quadro FX-3800
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = Xeon W3540
CPU Clock Speed = 2.93 Ghz
Cooing Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 4
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 12GB
RAM Manufacturer = Hynix
RAM Speed = 1066
Hard Drive Size = 180 Gb
Hard Drive Type and RPM = Intel SSD
_____________________________________________________________
I'm trying to figure out if it is worth upgrading to Xeon W3680 (passmark 9,178) from my current Xeon W3540 (passmark 5,442). I noticed during the simulation my processor speed was around 30% usage most of the time. The highest it went to was 50% and for the most part it is using all the cores on and off, CPU 6 was parked the whole time.
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Jared Conway Mar 18, 2014 12:39 AM (in response to Glenn Scully)see previous discussions about processors. go with fastest individual core over multiple cores. if the new processor is faster than the old one from a core to core perspective, it is probably a worthy upgrade. but be weary that not all simulations respond the same to hardware improvements. this is well documented in the KB. Also i'd recommend having someone take a look at your problem setups if the solve time is what you're trying to reduce. Generally this is done through improved setup vs throwing hardware at it.
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Glenn Scully Mar 20, 2014 12:34 PM (in response to Jared Conway)Ok thanks. The single threaded performance difference between the 2 chips is not great its really the 6 cores vs 4 cores that is the big difference.
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Jerry Steiger Mar 20, 2014 4:38 PM (in response to Glenn Scully)Glenn,
If the benchmark problem is representative of the type of work that you will be doing, then it doesn't look like 6 cores would help. From your comments, the benchmark normally only used two cores, sometimes going as high as three.
Jerry s.
-
-
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Bill Markert Mar 21, 2014 1:47 AM (in response to Glenn Scully)One of the problems I see in this discussion is the old data concerning 2012 and 2013 Simulation. I've run my i-7 3970x 3.5 Ghz machine across 2012 to 2014 SP2 and there is a big difference in the time the benchmark takes in the different versions. The greatest increase in performance comes in 2014 and is do to much better multicore utilization by the software. If memory serves 2012/2013 would only utilize 4 cores/8 threads and now 2014 utilizes all 6 cores/12 threads. Major time reduction over 2013 which, if I recall correctly, was actually slower than 2012. So if your running 2014 then the number of cores has a big impact, but I don't know what happens beyond 6 cores as that is all I have. Next biggest impact is core speed. I have overclocked my processor to 4.7 Ghz and I see significantly improved performance there. I actually routinely run the processor over clocked at 4.2 Ghz as it is rock solid stable there and I have never had any problems. I have also seen some small differences between the motherboard brands I've used but not enough to affect my work flow. I believe that the Xeon series of 8 core processors can't be over clocked so you don't see the higher processor speeds which would impact your performance. This may be the the cause of the slowdown you see in the data when your looking at the Xeon 8 core processors?
So if you have 2014 then I would recommend more cores with the fastest processor speed. It gets pricey though so you have to work your budget against the time savings. I would love to give a dual 2011 processor board with a couple of top of the line Xeons a test but that is way beyond my budget. IT departments may not be happy with the overclocks, but some machines come from vendors that way these days. I'm very pleased with my machine as I spend less time on routine problems setting up the simulations as the set up can be less efficient since I can solve so much faster than I could a few years ago. My old core duo quad core machine took about 45 minuites for the benchmark vs about 7 on my one year old 3970x setup.
Not sure this has any impact on Glenn's question but is food for thought. If he has access to 2014 he would pick up both the processor speed bump plus the additional core utilization. I would expect the 2012 bump would mostly be from the processor speed increase only.
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Matthew Jackson Mar 22, 2014 3:07 AM (in response to Bill Markert)Hello Everyone,
For a comparision and a bit of fun, I have run the benchmark test using my new Macbook Pro.
I have run the following simulations:
I have solved the following FE models:
- Iterative Solver Surface to Surface Contact
- Iterative Solver Node to Surface Contact
- Sparse Solver Surface to Surface Contact
- Sparse Solver Node to Surface Contact
- Large Sparse Solver Surface to Surface Contact
- Lage Sparse Solver Node to Surface Contact
My machine details are:
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2014/SP2
Computer Manufacturer = Apple
Computer Model = 15": 2.3 GHz with Retina Display
Approx System Cost = £2,200
Operating System and Service Pack = OS X Mavericks & Windows 7 Service Pack 1 (Bootcamp)
Graphics Card = NVIDIA GeForce GT 750M with 2GB GDRR5
CPU Brand = INTEL Quad-core
CPU Model = i7
CPU Clock Speed = 2.3 GHz with Turbo Boost to 3.5 GHz
Cooing Type = Air
Number of Cores = 4
Amount of RAM = 16GB
RAM Manufacturer =
RAM Speed = 1600 MHz DDR3L SDRAM
Hard Drive Size = 512 GB
Hard Drive Type and RPM = SSD
Results are:
Iterative Solver Surface to Surface Contact
Total Solution Time = 8 min 39 sec
Iterative Solver Node to Surface Contact
Total Solution Time = 8 min 26 sec
Sparse Solver Surface to Surface Contact
Total Solution Time = 13 min 35 sec
Sparse Solver Node to Surface Contact
Total Solution Time = 10 min 26 sec
Large Sparse Solver Surface to Surface Contact
Total Solution Time = 10 min 50 sec
Large Sparse Solver Node to Surface Contact
Total Solution Time = 10 min 54 sec
I also posted my old office PC solve times above on the 23rd April 2013, this PC has since 'packed in' as becuase it was overclocked so much it was very tempremental.
I think this gives a good comparision.
Thanks
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Glenn Scully Mar 29, 2014 7:52 PM (in response to Bill Markert)Bill,
That's great information on the imporvements that have been made in 2014 for utilizing multiple cores more efficiently. I tried out solidworks 2014 for a comparison on the same machine my time when from 17 minutes to 10 minutes. I can't believe the boost that 2014 gave it really makes good use of the 4 cores 8 threads that I currently have. The processor was at 80%+ for the majority of the simulation.
Total Solution Time (sec) = 615 (10 min 15 secons)
Number of Equations (490875) = Y
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2014/SP2.0
Computer Manufacturer = Dell
Computer Model = T3500
Approx System Cost = ($700 used)
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 64 SP1
Graphics Card = Nvdia Quadro FX-3800
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = Xeon W3540
CPU Clock Speed = 2.93 Ghz
Cooing Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 4
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 12GB
RAM Manufacturer = Hynix
RAM Speed = 1066
Hard Drive Size = 180 Gb
Hard Drive Type and RPM = Intel SSD
-
-
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Loke-Fong Koh Mar 31, 2014 8:57 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)Simulation Benchmark V3 Results
Total Solution Time (sec) = 688(11 min 28s)
Number of Equations (490875) = N (490038)
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2014 x64/SP1.0
Computer Manufacturer = Dell
Computer Model = Precision T5600
Approx System Cost =
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Professional x64/SP1
Graphics Card = nVidia Quadro 5000
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = Xeon(R) CPU E5-2665 (Eight Core, 2.40 GHz Turbo, 20MB, 8.0 GT/s) - 2 processors
CPU Clock Speed = 2.4 GHz
Cooling Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 8
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 32 GB
RAM Manufacturer =
RAM Speed = 1600 MHz
Hard Drive Size = 256 GB
Hard Drive Type and RPM = SSD
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Vittorio Villani Apr 2, 2014 5:44 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)Total Solution Time (sec) = 685
Number of Equations (490875) = 490038
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2014 x64/SP2.0
Computer Manufacturer =
Computer Model =
Approx System Cost =
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 8.1
Graphics Card = nVidia Quadro K6000
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = Xeon(R) CPU E5-2660 - 2 CPUs
CPU Clock Speed = 2.7 - 3.0 Ghz during benchmark
Cooling Type = Watercooling
Number of Cores = 2x8 (32 with HT)
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 4x8Gbyte (not optimal, 8 modules required for Quad Channel)
RAM Manufacturer =
RAM Speed = 1600 MHz
Hard Drive Size = 500Mbyte
Hard Drive Type and RPM = SSD RAID0 (2*Samsung EVO)
I had the opportunity to test this dual Xeon workstation based on an Asus Z9PE-D8 WS. CPU, motherboard and the K6000 are watercooled.
Hopefully I'll test a dual 2687W Xeon configuration in the next days.
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Vittorio Villani Apr 5, 2014 8:37 AM (in response to Vittorio Villani)Total Solution Time (sec) = 570
Number of Equations (490875) = 490038
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2014 x64/SP2.0
Computer Manufacturer =
Computer Model =
Approx System Cost =
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 8.1
Graphics Card = nVidia Quadro K6000
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = Xeon(R) CPU E5-2687W - 2 CPUs
CPU Clock Speed = 3.1 - 3.8 Ghz during benchmark
Cooling Type = Watercooling
Number of Cores = 2x8 (32 with HT)
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 4x8Gbyte (not optimal, 8 modules required for Quad Channel)
RAM Manufacturer =
RAM Speed = 1600 MHz
Hard Drive Size = 500Mbyte
Hard Drive Type and RPM = SSD RAID0 (2*Samsung EVO)
I have noticed that SolidWorks 2014 is using more cores and CPU power but we are far from optimal, other software benefit from this configuration a lot more.
I think that the best SolidWorkstaion right now should be based on an i7 4960x. Regarding the VGA is better not to talk about how useless is a Quadro K6000 with SW...
-
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Will Seeber Apr 8, 2014 7:50 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)Total Mesh Time (sec) = 15 sec
Total Solution Time (sec) = 458 sec (7.6 minutes)
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2014/SP2
Computer Manufacturer =Boxx
Computer Model = 4920 Xtreme
Approx System Cost = $5,200
Operating System and Service Pack = 7 Pro 64 bit
Graphics Card = Quadro 2000
CPU Brand = INTEL
CPU Model = i7-4960X Processor Extreme Edition
CPU Clock Speed = 4.6
Cooing Type = Liquid Cooled
Number of Cores = 6
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 24
RAM Manufacturer = Don't Know
RAM Speed = 1600
Hard Drive Size = 240
Hard Drive Type and RPM = Intel 730 Extreme, SSD
I am curious. Compare this with the post by Owen Buttigieg 10/8/2013. These machines should be similarly fast, but Owens is considerably faster. The biggest difference that I see is that he has a Quadro 4000 and I have a Quadro 2000. The video card should make no difference. We compared a 600 and the 2000 and found nearly identical performance for an FEA solution.
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Will Seeber Apr 8, 2014 8:15 PM (in response to Will Seeber)Concerning Buttigieg results that are faster than ours.
T O T A L S Y S T E M D A T A
NUMBER OF EQUATIONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(NEQ) = 490038
NUMBER OF ELEMENTS. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(NUME) = 111897
NUMBER OF NODAL POINTS. . . . . . . . . . . . .(NUMNP)= 167686
T O T A L S O L U T I O N T I M E (sec) . . . . = 363
These are the the results he posted from the output file.
T O T A L S Y S T E M D A T A
NUMBER OF EQUATIONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(NEQ) = 1847682
NUMBER OF ELEMENTS. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(NUME) = 430890
NUMBER OF NODAL POINTS. . . . . . . . . . . . .(NUMNP)= 620114
These are our results. It appears he may have used a courser mesh. This would mean the results are not really comparable.
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Russ Johnston Apr 9, 2014 8:19 AM (in response to Will Seeber)This is typical of not following Step 3 in the instructions...
3. Under the Simulation drop down menu, go to “Options” --> “Default Options” --> “Mesh” and check that the “Show advanced options for contact set definition” option is turned ON.
-
-
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Phil Perlich Apr 9, 2014 10:05 AM (in response to Russ Johnston)I got a new machine last week. Here are the results this time around:
Total Solution Time (sec) = 623 sec (10 min, 23 sec)
Number of Equations (490875) = No, 490038
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2014/SP2.0
Computer Manufacturer = Dell
Computer Model = T5610
Approx System Cost =
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Pro SP1
Graphics Card = NVIDIA Quadro K4000
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = Xeon E5-2630 v2
CPU Clock Speed = 2.6 GHz
Cooing Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = (2) 6-core processors
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = No?
Amount of RAM = 32 GB
RAM Manufacturer = ?
RAM Speed = ?
Hard Drive Size = D: = 238 GB (SSD only used for SW); C: 224 GB (Disk used for everything else)
Hard Drive Type and RPM = SSD; disk speed ?
EDIT: Forgot to attach the .OUT file
Message was edited by: Phil Perlich
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Shaun Galloway May 5, 2014 5:55 AM (in response to Russ Johnston)Total Solution Time (sec) = 625
Number of Equations (490875) = N (490038)
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2014/SP3
Computer Manufacturer = Dell
Computer Model = M6700
Approx System Cost = £2000
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Professional x64 sp1.0
Graphics Card = NVIDIA Quadro K3000M
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = i7-3740QM
CPU Clock Speed = 2.7GHz
Cooing Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 4
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 16Gb
RAM Manufacturer = NANYA TECHNOLOGY
RAM Speed = 1600
Hard Drive Size = 256GB SAMSUNG SM841
Hard Drive Type and RPM = SSD
Misc Notes:
Using direct sparse, with all other settings the same, gave a solution time of 1066s.
-
FEA_BENCHMARK-V3.txt.zip 4.3 KB
-
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Eric Andersen May 15, 2014 1:38 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)Got a new workstation!
Total Solution Time (sec) = 1119
Number of Equations (490875) = N (490038)
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2013/SP2
Computer Manufacturer = Dell
Computer Model = T3610
Approx System Cost = $2000
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Professional x64 sp1.0
Graphics Card = AMD FirePro W5000 (4GB)
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = Xeon E5-1620 v2
CPU Clock Speed = 3.70 GHz
Cooing Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 4
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 16Gb
RAM Manufacturer = OEM
RAM Speed = 1600
Hard Drive Size = 1 TB
Hard Drive Type and RPM = 7200 RPM
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Andrew Francisco May 16, 2014 12:30 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)Total Solution Time (sec) = 662
Number of Equations (490875) = N (490038)
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2014/SP0
Computer Manufacturer =Custom (Me)
Computer Model = n/a
Approx System Cost = ~ $1200
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Ultimate S.P 1
Graphics Card = AMD FirePro w5000 2GB
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = 2700k
CPU Clock Speed = 4.5ghz
Cooing Type = Air Cooled (Cooler Master 212 Hyper Evo)
Number of Cores = 4
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 16gb
RAM Manufacturer = Corsair
RAM Speed = 1600mhz DDR3
Hard Drive Size = 240gb
Hard Drive Type and RPM = 2x Agility 3 SSD (Raid 0)
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Owen Buttigieg Oct 13, 2014 7:57 AM (in response to Andrew Francisco)Ok I have a new workstation,
Intel Core i7 5960X Extreme Haswell-E 8-Core LGA 2011-3 3.0GHz CPU Processor
ASUS X99-DELUXE Intel LGA 2011-3 ATX Motherboard
NVIDIA Quadro 4000
Corsair Hydro Series H110 Liquid CPU Cooler
EVGA SuperNOVA 1000W G2 80 Plus Gold Modular Power Supply
Crucial 8GB (1x 8GB) DDR4 2133MHz Desktop Memory CT8G4DFD8213
Samsung 840 EVO 1tb
I have a stable overclock at 4.5Ghz. The temps are under 70 degC under full load for most of the cores.
T O T A L S Y S T E M D A T A
NUMBER OF EQUATIONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(NEQ) = 490038
NUMBER OF ELEMENTS. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(NUME) = 111897
NUMBER OF NODAL POINTS. . . . . . . . . . . . .(NUMNP)= 167686
T O T A L S O L U T I O N T I M E (sec) . . . . = 329
So not a great improvement. Mesh time was still 7 sec. There is definitely a increase in smoothness and general snappyness but that could also be the new installation of Windows.
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Owen Buttigieg Oct 15, 2014 2:12 AM (in response to Owen Buttigieg)Ok I have done some tweaking if anybody interested. I have a 125Mhz bus with a multiplier of 37 to achieve 4625Mhz. I did get a clock od 4.6 with a 100 bus but the performance did not change and the solution was slightly slower. It just made a little more heat and no gain. I also have the ram clocked at 1333Mhz for 2666Mhz. The ram I have is only good for 2133Mhz so I have adjusted the timings to 16,18,18,36 clocks which is quite stable. I am not having any temperature issues and it is currently 28degC in my office. I would probably expect and good result from the 5930k as well. Looking for ward to what other people can get. Also the cpu does throttle with the power saving during the analysis. I might even try switching all c states off and see what happens because the mesh creation is done at the base clock speed.
T O T A L S Y S T E M D A T A
NUMBER OF EQUATIONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(NEQ) = 490038
NUMBER OF ELEMENTS. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(NUME) = 111897
NUMBER OF NODAL POINTS. . . . . . . . . . . . .(NUMNP)= 167686
T O T A L S O L U T I O N T I M E (sec) . . . . = 295
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Owen Buttigieg Oct 15, 2014 2:40 AM (in response to Owen Buttigieg)Ok,
Turning off all the power saving options resulted in a mesh time of 6 seconds and a solve time of 284 seconds. I did have one core hit 80 degC during the solve but most were below 70 and av was 60 degC. So I think for the average user the power saving options could be left on I know I certainly will to save on electricity. Have fun and if your not your own boss, beg borrow and steal for an upgrade. I think it will pay off for me because some of the models I solve take hours.
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Jared Conway Oct 15, 2014 6:11 PM (in response to Owen Buttigieg)how long do you think the CPU can survive at those speeds?
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Owen Buttigieg Oct 15, 2014 9:25 PM (in response to Jared Conway)How long will it last, I don't know. I have had my 3930k clocked at 4.6 for nearly 3 years and it hasn't missed a beat. I have power saving mode enabled so it is in idle mode most of the time. I just ran the same analysis with 6 cores and found that the solve time was not considerably different. It was actually slightly better.
T O T A L S Y S T E M D A T A
NUMBER OF EQUATIONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(NEQ) = 490038
NUMBER OF ELEMENTS. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(NUME) = 111897
NUMBER OF NODAL POINTS. . . . . . . . . . . . .(NUMNP)= 167686
T O T A L S O L U T I O N T I M E (sec) . . . . = 293
-
-
-
-
-
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Nivil Thomas Oct 19, 2014 8:31 AM (in response to Russ Johnston)Total Solution Time (sec) = 966 sec(16 min 6 sec)
Number of Equations (490875) = N (490038)
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2014/SP4
Computer Manufacturer =Custom
Computer Model =Custom
Approx System Cost = $2100
Operating System and Service Pack = Win 7 Pro x64 SP1
Graphics Card = Nvidia Quadro K4000(320.78)
CPU Brand =Intel
CPU Model = i7-4770
CPU Clock Speed =3.4 GHz
Cooing Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 4
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 16 GB
RAM Manufacturer = Kingston
RAM Speed =1600 MHz
Hard Drive Size = 128 GB Corsair Force GS SCSI
Hard Drive Type and RPM = SSD
Misc Notes:
Gigabyte Z87-HD3 motherboard.
-
FEA_BENCHMARK-V3-Study 1.zip 3.9 KB
-
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Dave Laban Nov 25, 2014 6:10 AM (in response to Russ Johnston)Total Solution Time (sec) = 645
Number of Equations (490875) = N (490038)
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2014/SP3
Computer Manufacturer = HP
Computer Model = Z820
Approx System Cost = $Lots
Operating System and Service Pack = Win 7 Enterprise x64 SP1
Graphics Card = Nvidia Quadro K4000
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = Xeon E5-2670 v2 x2
CPU Clock Speed = 2.50GHz
Cooing Type = Air
Number of Cores = 20 real (10 real per proc)
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 16Gb
RAM Manufacturer = Unknown
RAM Speed = Unknown
Hard Drive Size = 1TB
Hard Drive Type and RPM = Mechanical, 7200rpm
Will post again when my RAID SSD array gets installed, should make for an interesting comparison vs. the archaic 7200rpm drive.
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Chris Ross Feb 21, 2015 10:46 AM (in response to Russ Johnston)Just got in my new laptop. Very pleased so far at its speed.
Total Solution Time (sec) = 402
Number of Equations (490875) = N (490038)
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2014/SP5
Computer Manufacturer = Dell
Computer Model = Precision M6800 Laptop
Approx System Cost = $5k
Operating System and Service Pack = Win 7 Professional x64 SP1
Graphics Card = Nvidia Quadro K5100M
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = i7-4940MX
CPU Clock Speed = 3.1 GHz
Cooing Type = Air
Number of Cores = 4 real
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 32Gb
RAM Manufacturer = Unknown
RAM Speed = 1600MHz DDR3L
Hard Drive Size = 1TB
Hard Drive Type and RPM = Samsung SSD 850 Pro
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Matt Langford Feb 27, 2015 4:05 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)Simulation Benchmark V3 Results
Total Solution Time (sec) = 201s
Number of Equations (490875) = Y
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2015/SP2.0
Computer Manufacturer = XI Computer
Computer Model = MTower
Approx System Cost = $4000
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Professional x64/SP1
Graphics Card = nVidia Quadro K620
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = i7 5960X
CPU Clock Speed = 4.08 GHz
Cooling Type = Liquid Cooled
Number of Cores = 8 physical
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 32 GB
RAM Manufacturer = Corsair
RAM Speed = 2800 MHz
Hard Drive Size = 250 GB Samsung 850 EVO
Hard Drive Type and RPM = SSD
Misc Notes: Runs in 217s with Hyperthreading Disabled
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Edwin Michna Feb 27, 2015 7:21 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)Simulation Benchmark V3 Results
Total Solution Time (sec) = 860
Number of Equations (490875) = 490875
Active Contact Elements (28) = 28
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2012/SP5.0
Computer Manufacturer = Dell
Computer Model = M6600
Approx System Cost = ~$3500
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Professional x64 sp1.0
Graphics Card = NVIDIA Quadro 4000M
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = i7-2860QM
CPU Clock Speed = 2.5 GHz
Cooling Type = air Cooled
Number of Cores = 4
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 32 GB
RAM Manufacturer = ?
RAM Speed = ? MHz
Hard Drive Size = 240 GB
Hard Drive Type and RPM = SSD
Misc Notes: Windows Ultra Performance power setting
-
FEA_BENCHMARK-V3-Study 1.zip 4.2 KB
-
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Justin Strempke Jul 16, 2015 11:03 AM (in response to Russ Johnston)Total Solution Time (sec) = 365
Number of Equations (490875) = N (490038)
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2015/SP4.0x64
Computer Manufacturer = Dell
Computer Model = M6700
Approx System Cost = $5k
Operating System and Service Pack = Win 7.1 Ultimate SP1
Graphics Card = Nvidia Quadro K4000M
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = i7-3840QM
CPU Clock Speed = 2.8 GHz
Cooing Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 4
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 16 GB
RAM Manufacturer = Unknown
RAM Speed = Unknown
Hard Drive Size = 512 GB
Hard Drive Type and RPM = Samsung 850 Pro
Misc Notes:
Older thread but still relevant to see how the SW sim progression is getting. My laptop now is 3x quicker than my super-desktop from two years ago
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Stephen White Jul 18, 2015 5:09 AM (in response to Russ Johnston)Total Solution Time (sec) = 350
Number of Equations (490875) = N - 490038
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2015/SP3
Computer Manufacturer = DELL
Computer Model = M6800
Approx System Cost = Unknown
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 8.1 Pro
Graphics Card = NVIDIA Quadro K3100M
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = i7-4800MQ
CPU Clock Speed = 2.7GHz
Cooing Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 8
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = N
Amount of RAM = 32GB
RAM Manufacturer = Unknown
RAM Speed = 800
Hard Drive Size = 256GB
Hard Drive Type and RPM = LITEONIT LCS-256M6S 2.5 7mm SSD
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Michael Schrider Oct 30, 2015 4:31 PM (in response to Stephen White)Total Solution Time (sec) = 260
Number of Equations (490875) = 490038
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2016/SP0.0
Computer Manufacturer = Dell
Computer Model = Precision Tower 7810 XCTO Base
Approx System Cost = $5300 (3/2015)
Operating System and Service Pack = WINDOWS 7 PROFESSIONAL SP 1
Graphics Card = Nvidia Quadro K2200 4GB
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = Xeon Processor E5-2687W v3
CPU Clock Speed = 3.1GHz Turbo
Cooing Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 20
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 32GB (4x8GB)
RAM Manufacturer = Unknown
RAM Speed = 2133MHz DDR4 RDIMM ECC
Hard Drive Size = 360GB & 512GB
Hard Drive Type and RPM = (OS & Programs) 360GB SATA SSD; (Data) 512GB SATA SSD
-
FEA_BENCHMARK-V3-Study 1.zip 4.8 KB
-
-
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
James Santangelo Jul 14, 2017 4:52 PM (in response to Russ Johnston)Total Solution Time (sec) = 321
Number of Equations (490875) = N 490038, "Show advanced options for contact set definition" was checked.
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2016 / SP4
Computer Manufacturer = Lenovo
Computer Model = ThinkPad P51
Approx System Cost = $2,100
Operating System and Service Pack = Win 10 Pro x64, version 1703, OS Build 15063.483
Graphics Card = nVidia Quadro M2200 4GB
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = Xeon E3-1505M v6
CPU Clock Speed = 3.0 GHz Base, 3.6 GHz Turbo
Cooling Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 4
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 32 GB (2x 16 GB)
RAM Manufacturer = Crucial
RAM Speed = 2400 MHz ECC
Hard Drive Size = 500 GB
Hard Drive Type and RPM = Samsung 960 EVO NVMe
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Philip Christensen Oct 26, 2017 8:53 AM (in response to Russ Johnston)Total Solution Time (sec) = 134s
Number of Equations (490875) = N 490038, "Show advanced options for contact set definition" was checked.
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2017/SP4.1
Computer Manufacturer = Dell
Computer Model = Precision 7720
Approx System Cost = $5,000
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 10 Enterprise, version 1607, OS Build 14393.1715
Graphics Card = NVidia Quadro P4000 with 8GB DDR5
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = Xeon CPU E3-1535M v6
CPU Clock Speed=3.10GHz, 4.2GHz turbo
Cooling Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 4
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 32GB (2x16GB)
RAM Manufacturer = Unknown
RAM Speed = 2400 MHz ECC
Hard Drive Size = 256 GB
Hard Drive Type and RPM = Samsung NVMe PM961
-
Re: SolidWorks Simulation Benchmark V3
Philip Christensen Oct 26, 2017 9:10 AM (in response to Russ Johnston)Total Solution Time (sec) = 186s
Number of Equations (490875) = N 490038, "Show advanced options for contact set definition" was checked.
Active Contact Elements (28) = Y
SolidWorks Version and Service Pack = SW2017/SP3.0
Computer Manufacturer = Dell
Computer Model = Precision T5600
Approx System Cost = $?
Operating System and Service Pack = Windows 7 Enterprise, version 6.1.7601 SP1 Build 7601
Graphics Card = NVidia Quadro 4000
CPU Brand = Intel
CPU Model = Xeon CPU E5-2687W (2 processors)
CPU Clock Speed = 3.10GHz
Cooling Type = Air Cooled
Number of Cores = 8
Hyper-Threading Enabled? = Y
Amount of RAM = 32GB
RAM Manufacturer = Unknown
RAM Speed = Unknown
Hard Drive Size = 256 GB (SSD) + 500 GB (HDD)
Hard Drive Type and RPM = Dell Perc H310 + Hitachi HTS72505





