11 Replies Latest reply on Sep 8, 2018 1:28 AM by Igor Fomenko

    Can you "lock" a configuration

    Shawn Casebolt

      Is it possible to lock a configuration from ever changing?

       

      Ill give a simple example.  I have a board, this board has different cutouts, of varying sizes and locations.  Therefore I have different configurations, with cuts suppressed/unsuppressed.  The location and size dims modified for the ones that are turned on.

       

      Once I have it like I need, I want that configuration locked.  It seems everytime I make a new configuration.  Sometime, somewhere, somehow I forget to check the "this configuration only" box.  Then I have to go through all the configs, see which ones are AFU and fix them.  As the file grows, this becomes impractical.  Any ideas?

        • Re: Can you "lock" a configuration
          Antun Gkovacevic

          Can a configuration of a part or assembly be locked so it cannot be edited?

           

          This is currently a limitation in the software. 

          This limitation has been reported to SolidWorks development team as SPR# 266538

          -----------------

           

          Maybe someone has another solution for this problem?

          • Re: Can you "lock" a configuration
            Scott McFadden

            I don't know of a way to lock the configuration, but have you thought about creating

            a design table?  This way you go into one file, and control everything there.

            • Re: Can you "lock" a configuration
              Don Vanzile

              Sometimes what I do when I have a complex file with configurations and I want to start "playing" is autocreate a design table and save it out to a file.  That way, if I really hose something I can just go back in time by bringing the design table back into the file.

              • Re: Can you "lock" a configuration

                I use design tables for 75% of my work and that keeps roaming fingers from messing with my models. Seeing that I'm the only person who does the solidworks designing.

                They think its easy till they try it and mess it up.

                • Re: Can you "lock" a configuration
                  Ryan Werner

                  I have to say that using a design table is probably the best idea.  However, if you do not want to set that up than you could take the time and use the Configure Feature option.  I have found that this works pretty well in this type of situation.  Just go through your features and suppress or unsuppress them using the Configure Feature table and then everytime you add another feature that you want to control in configurations just do the same thing for that feature.  It may not "lock" it as well as a design table but it will work better than going through each configuration and suppressing each feature individually.  

                  • Re: Can you "lock" a configuration
                    Tyler Nichol

                    I would realllllllllly like to see lockable configurations implemented in SolidWorks. Despite my lobbying, our company has decided to not use configurations to represent multiple similar-but-different parts. This is because our PLM/PDM system cannot cope with changes to some configurations but not to others: it sees a change to any configuration as a change to every configuration. Even though we can revise individual configs, we cannot check-out the revised configs while others are still released.

                     

                    If SolidWorks enables a configuration locking feature, only then can I go to PTC to ask them to enable Windchill to recognize locked configurations and allow checking-out of unlocked configurations only. Which would make my life and the lives of my fellow designers significantly less frustrating.

                     

                    Please vote for SPR# 266538! It's been 8 years!

                      • Re: Can you "lock" a configuration
                        Stephen Lapic

                        While design tables are pretty effective for controlling some of the issues not everything can be on a design table.  We have had people accidently change one configuration when it was supposed to be another.  Later on someone checks it and notices the mistake on the newer config because that is what they are checking but not on the original config.  This can cascade into assemblies then.

                         

                        I agree with Tyler to vote for SPR# 266538 as an enhancement.

                      • Re: Can you "lock" a configuration
                        S. Leacox

                        Lock. No.

                        However, you can pick if the table is in charge or not. So everything but the table is locked, or the table if fed by changes to specific dimensions in each config.

                        • Re: Can you "lock" a configuration
                          Igor Fomenko

                          Very good idea! Especially for assemblies, bolt assemblies like this one

                          I have a lot of configurations of diameter and thickness of part package and I have to correct configurations of bolt, nut and washers often because of my mistake when I add a new config.