6 Replies Latest reply on Aug 15, 2010 1:25 AM by Anna Wood

    Workstation for Simulation (analysis)......

    Noel Rodes

      We have just acquired Flowworks to compliment our existing Simulation Premium and are looking to purchase a workstation to dedicate to analysis.  The company is pretty much Dell hardware, but not necessarily so.

      What would be a good workstation?  CPU?  Memory?  etc., etc., etc.?????

        • Re: Workstation for Simulation (analysis)......

          It has been a year since I purchased a computer so I am sure there are newer and better systems out there. We had a $5,000 limit which limited my choice. Here is a list of the Dell Box:


          Dell Precision Workstation T7400

          Windows XP-64 Operating System

          8GB Memory

          1.5GB FX4800 Graphics Card

          500 GB SATA 3.0Gb/s, 7200 RPM Hard Drive


          The more memory and better graphic card you can afford the better.

          • Re: Workstation for Simulation (analysis)......
            Dan Markoff

            64b operating system with as much memory as you can get is an absolute must.  I ran out of memory all the time when running simulations in xp 32b, even with 4GB installed.

            • Re: Workstation for Simulation (analysis)......
              Josh Krumheuer

              Simulation is also very dependant on the CPU, don't skimp on that either.  It would really help if you had a budget.

              • Re: Workstation for Simulation (analysis)......
                David Paulson

                I'm running Flow on Xeon E5440 quad core processor with 8 GB of DRAM, an Intel X25M SSD boot drive (applications too) and two Veloicraptors in RAID 1.  Flow Performance on this system is excellent.


                It could be improved by adding one more processor for 8 cores total and 8 GB more DRAM for a total of 16 GB if your budget allows.  Flow does take advantage of 4+ cores.  

                  • Re: Workstation for Simulation (analysis)......
                    Noel Rodes

                    Thanks for the replies.


                    How about:  xeon x5680, 12g ddr3 1333 mem, 300g sas 15k rpm drive?  win7 64bit.    Dell  $5625


                    or i7-980X @ 3.59GHz, 12g ddr3 1333 mem, 300g sas 15k rpm drive, win7-64?   @Xi $4249


                    both with nominal videos.


                    I do like the idea of a ssd boot drive, particularly to put the swap space in.

                      • Re: Workstation for Simulation (analysis)......
                        Anna Wood

                        I think I would go with the Dell for no other reason then I have not heard anything good about Xi when it comes to support after the sale.  However there are other plusses for the Dell.


                        I am assuming the Dell you are looking at is a T5500 or T7500 series Precision Workstation.  Those are dual socket motherboards.  When combined with a Xeon 5600 series cpu you will have the option of having both cpu sockets filled on the mobo.  This would be 12 cores (or 24 with hyper-threading enabled) if you purchased 2 cpu's.  I suspect you will also be able to load up the Dell with more memory then the Xi system.


                        The Core i7's are great processors, they are marketed for the enthusiast/gamer.  Because of how Intel is marketing them they can only be used on a single socket system.  This is one big reason the Xi is less expensive compared to the Dell.


                        SSD's are very nice.  I have an OCZ Vertex in my computer and it is very peppy.  They are very high cost though per gig.  You need to decide if the speed increase offers the ROI to justify the costs. I suspect it will if you do a lot of FEA.


                        If buying the Dell for a corporate account you may be able to negotiate a better price.  We never pay the price on the web for Dell computers with our corporate account.


                        Another thing you can check on is buying only the minimal amount of memory on the Dell.  Then look at after market memory modules, they are often less expensive then buying from Dell.  Check out Crucial and Kingston and do a price comparison.  You may be able to save a good chunk of money.


                        My money is on the Dell for your situation with heavy FEA use.