Caleb this is likely a Windows scaling issue.
Try right clicking your desktop and going Personalize and see if there is an option to use 100% scaling (you may be using 125)
Also in SW from this menu, change the button scaling to Small (Default).
If using a 4K monitor, try a standard resolution (1920 x 1080) as a test.
Also close SW. Right click the desktop icon and choose Properties and tick this box.
you may be using the 2016-17 version of SW where scaling needed some work- 2017-18 is better.
hopefully one of these helps.
Tried the above, but still no luck. Also tried using SW with external monitor, but having the same issue.