1 Reply Latest reply on Feb 9, 2017 2:51 PM by Keith Frankie

    Simulation of Carrier

    Syed Kashif Ali Subzwari

      Hello,

       

      I am trying to simulate the performance of a carrier used in metal ceilings to carry the panels on it. The carrier is supported with a adjustment clip hanger which is fixed on the concrete ceiling. The problem I am facing is the difference in results I get when I simulate the carrier as a single part and when I simulate the carrier and the hanger as an assembly. The results dont compliment each other creating a doubt on the boundary conditions used for simulation.

      I have attached the images showing the simulation loads, fixtures and the results for the part and the assembly simulation. I have also added an image showing the adjustment clip hanger with the rod for reference.

      Can you please suggest which are the ideal loads and fixtures that should be used in such cases.

       

      Any help will be much appreciated.

       

      Thanks in advance.

        • Re: Simulation of Carrier
          Keith Frankie

          My guess is that the different results plot scales are confusing the interpretation of the results.

           

          In the assembly model a lot of "stretch" happens in the hangers, thus the red areas represent 4 mm of movement.  In the part by itself the whole thing only sags down half a mm.  If you rescale the assembly results to show deformations between 3.5 mmm (min) and 4 mm (max) it will probably look very similar (to the part study).