6 Replies Latest reply on Oct 5, 2015 1:28 PM by Andrei Popov

    Flow simulation on Boat

    Joseph Kim
    Joseph Kim Oct 2, 2015 5:00 AM

      Hello,


      I am a Mech Eng student and I am only learning to use solidworks as I work through a number of projects in Uni.
      Anyways, I have been looking all over the forum but it does not seem to have the question I need answered.
      I am trying to calculate a drag force using the flow simulation on the boat. (a floating body)
      I know it can easily calculate the force on bodies entirely submerged in water. But is it possible to calculate the force if the body is partially submerged in water?
      Two phase fluid external flow can not be done with Solidworks(as I read somewhere), but would it be possible to calculate the force due to each fluid(air/water) separately and add them up?? (given I can figure out where the boat is submerged). I understand the results would not be accurate. However as long as I can get somewhat reasonable value, that will do for the current project I am doing.

       

      Thanks in advance

      • 2988 Views
      • Categories: Flow Simulation, Simulation
      • Tags:
        • Re: Flow simulation on Boat
          Amit Katz
          Amit Katz Oct 2, 2015 9:21 AM (in response to Joseph Kim)

          I think what you're asking for is theoretically feasible, however it comes with some big caveats that depend on the length scale of your boat and the relative speeds. You can have gas and liquid subdomains in the same simulation, but they will not mix, nor will their surfaces interact. That means you will not be able to model bow waves and a true wake. The amount of drag that these phenomena contribute depends on how big your boat is, and how fast it's going. Really the only legitimate simulation I can imagine for this thing is extremely low Reynolds number flow (and that  value will of course vary widely between the air and water as well.) Otherwise you're going to be ignoring too many mechanics to get a real accurate model.

            • Re: Flow simulation on Boat
              Joseph Kim
              Joseph Kim Oct 2, 2015 9:46 AM (in response to Amit Katz)

              Yes. I understand. The thing is, this approach would be also ignoring the effects of planning as the speed of the boat increases. (which I assume will result in less drag) I am only trying it this way as I can not think of any other viable way to predict the drag force.  (All the journal articles I looked into seem to use dimensional analysis with experimental values from model) I would use any method even if it does not involve CFD as long as I can get some approximate values. 


              To be more specific, I am modelling an RC boat travelling at the maximum speed. so the overall length would be something like 1m with the speed of 85km/h.


              Anyways, if I was to just simulate it with two phases, do I need to first make a plane surface separating the water and air and use that to split the computational domain into two subdomains?

            • Re: Flow simulation on Boat
              Brian Stranyak
              Brian Stranyak Oct 2, 2015 9:34 AM (in response to Joseph Kim)

              I showed this to a colleague who's son is in naval architecture school. His response was this "There are lots of resistance prediction models depending on hull type. That's probably the fella's best bet. SNAME has a publication called Principles of Naval Architecture. Volume 2 is all about resistance." I don't know what any of this is for my line of work

                • Re: Flow simulation on Boat
                  Joseph Kim
                  Joseph Kim Oct 2, 2015 10:06 AM (in response to Brian Stranyak)

                  I just skimmed through the publication and it seems to suggest three methods,  numerical, experimental and empirical. I won't be able to do a numerical or experimental as I have got no idea how. (formulas presented seem to require computational calculation). Maybe the empirical method could be done thru hand calculation? Anyways Thanks heaps I will look into it more

                • Re: Flow simulation on Boat
                  Amit Katz
                  Amit Katz Oct 2, 2015 10:06 AM (in response to Joseph Kim)

                  To be honest, I don't believe that you're going to get any sort of benefit from modeling the boat like this. A more powerful CFD package may help, but I think you might be stuck with practical experiments in this case.