# Force calculation does not agree with plotted variables

Question asked by Amit Katz on Jan 22, 2015
Latest reply on Jan 27, 2015 by Jared Conway

I have a simulation of a solid object resting on a perforated drum, with a vacuum pressure behind, as pictured: Please focus only on the highlighted face and ignore the rest.

As you can see there are only a few places where there is solid-fluid contact, namely at the holes (which are 5mm in diameter.) The pressure is approximately uniform, a -25 inches of water. Only 12 of the holes have vacuum pressure. Neglecting friction, one would expect the force on this solid to be = 12 x (25 inches H2O) x pi() x (2.5mm)^2. This equation is equal to approximately 150 gram-force (http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=3*4*25+in+wc*pi*%282.5mm%29%5E2+to+gram-force).

When I do a surface parameter on this face I get this result from Flow Sim:

 Integral Parameter Value X-component Y-component Z-component Surface Area [in^2] Normal Force [grf] 1745.461 -1202.013 -1265.621 -3.873e-004 0.3972 Force [grf] 1745.461 -1202.013 -1265.621 -3.872e-004 0.3972

As you can see the force and normal force are identical, there is no shear force. The error here is not small, it is a factor of 10 off from what I would expect. Does anybody know why this would be? Did I miss something?